New Delhi, March 21 (IANS) As India prepares to vote for its 16th Lok Sabha, eminent academicians say poll coverage in a section of the media was biased.
Speaking at a discussion on "Media and election; Manufacturing consent" here late Thursday, social scientist Zoya Hasan referred to American philosopher and social scientist Noam Chomsky's theory of manufacturing consent.
She said that in case of the 2014 general elections, media had a role in manufacturing a dissent, before moving to manufacturing consent.
"The coverage of the 2014 Lok Sabha polls actually started in 2012 when Narendra Modi became the Gujarat chief minister for a third time. The speculations about whether he will be BJP's prime ministerial candidate started then," said Zoya Hasan at the event held at the India International Centre here.
Hasan said media, or sections of it, first "created dissent" slamming the current government, and alleged that it subsequently became a "corporate-backed agenda to promote Modi as someone who can provide decisive leadership".
"In this case, the media first manufactured dissent, calling the UPA corrupt, talking about the policy paralysis... which was also due to the time taken in land acquisition and environment clearances. The middle class was already angry with the economic slowdown," said Hasan.
"The political discourse has been limited to the shortcomings of the Congress leadership, and the Gujarat model of development," she said.
Hasan also pointed out that a picture is being drawn that nothing has happened since independence. "Being told that nothing happened in the last 60 years is troubling for a social scientist," she said.
Sudha Pai, professor of political science at the Jawaharlal Nehru University here, said that while Chomsky's theory was not about elections, it could be applied here. The theory of manufacturing consent by Chomsky, in the context of the American media, argued that mainstream media can be a propaganda organ for the elite establishment of society to force its opinion and views on the rest of society.
"Chomsky's theory was about a nexus of government, and corporate propagating through advertisements. It was not in context of elections but it can be applied here," said Pai.
She, however, added that the diverse and multicultural nature of India's demography limited the impact of media.
"In England, France or Germany, it is easier to manufacture consent. But Indian polity is complex with many parties, and its regional nature," said Pai.
"Is press all that powerful? The size and diversity of the country makes it difficult and the effects are more localised. Many local politicians own TV channels," she pointed out.
Historian Mukul Kesvan, who teaches at Jamia Millia Islamia, said media coverage about the elections not only lacked information but was suspect in its credibility.
"Media coverage in the runup to general elections lacks information. In TV journalism, there is a vast amount of unsourced discussion," said Kesavan.
Vidya Subramaniam, a senior journalist with The Hindu, said "media humdrum" during the 2004 general elections on the NDA's 'India Shining' campaign failed to make an impact.
"In 2004, media was full of 'India Shining' campaign. However, a social movement was going on at the ground level which no one noticed. When the results came, the Congress was leading and the UPA came to power," she said.
PM Modi's 50KM long road show in Ahmedabad today: said in Panchmahal - Congress is competing to abuse me
In Gujarat, Prime Minister Narendra Modi held an election rally in the Panchmahal district on Thursday. He said that there is a competition in Congress to abuse me. The more mud is thrown, the more
Who threatens China? / President Xi Jinping told the army - Keeping the most difficult situation in mind, speed up the preparations for war
Beijing Chinese President Xi-Jinping has asked the army to speed up training and preparations for war. Keeping yourself in mind of the most difficult situation, prepare yourself and stay strong for
A record 3.32 lakh new patients were found in 24 hours, this figure crossed 3 lakh for the second consecutive day; But the relief is also good 1.92 lakhs
Two very bad and one good news for all of us. The pace of Corona in the country is not taking a name. New records of statistics are being made every day. Within the last 24 hours, the highest number
Pakistan Politics: ...then civil war will break out in Pakistan, why did former PM Imran Khan say so?
Pakistan Politics: Pakistan's deposed Prime Minister Imran Khan has warned that the country will plunge into civil war if new elections are not announced. According to the 'Dawn' newspaper, in an
Mitchell Marsh confident of filling in Faulkner's shoes
Melbourne, Feb 9 (IANS) Australian all-rounder Mitchell Marsh Monday said he is “pretty confident” of filling in for injured James Faulkner, who is expected to be fit till the side's
He used to tweet abusive words from my handle and I was getting slander .... Dinesh Trivedi explained the reasons for leaving TMC
Former TMC leader Dinesh Trivedi, who resigned from the Rajya Sabha last week, has targeted electoral strategist Prashant Kishore and Mamata Banerjee's nephew Abhishek Banerjee, among the reasons for
Little girl injured by Rohit's SIX: Hitman hit a pull shot off David Willey's ball, the match was halted for 5 minutes
The first match of the three-match ODI series between India and England was played at The Oval on Tuesday. During the Indian innings, a small girl was injured by a shot by Team India captain Rohit
Modi invokes Lord Ram at Faizabad
Lucknow, May 5 (IANS) BJP's prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi Monday invoked the name of Lord Ram in an election speech and urged the people to vote out the "corrupt and incompetent
All judges of the Supreme Court will hear from their home today, many members of staff feared being infected
The impact of the second wave of Corona in the country has reached the Supreme Court. If sources are to be believed, many members of the Supreme Court staff are corona infected. As a precaution, all
Buy Earbuds from Samsung, Sony, and OnePlus for less than 5 thousand rupees, a 75% discount is available in Amazon Sale!
Amazon Great Indian Festival Sale: There are huge discounts on Samsung's great earbuds on Amazon. Active noise cancellation technology and 3-mic earbuds are available in the sale at a discount of 75%.