New Delhi, March 18 (IANS) The central government on Wednesday strongly opposed the plea seeking to restrain it from setting up a panel to make appointments to the higher judiciary, replacing the collegium system, telling the Supreme Court that the plea was "premature, academic and without cause" and the new system should be allowed to work first to see its efficacy.
Contending that the plea to stay the enforcing of National Judicial Appointment Commission Act, 2014 was "abstract, bereft of facts, bereft of injuries, or bereft of the facts that the body of the lawyers who are opposing it would be affected", Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi asked the bench of Justice Anil R. Dave, Justice J. Chelameswar and Justice Madan B. Lokur whether elected members of parliament should "have no say in the appointment of judges".
Making a plea against the court stepping in at this stage, he said: "It is always in the course of implementation or trial some difficulties will arise and they can always be corrected. Allow it to work. Only then court can examine whether this (collegium system) is better or that (NJAC) is better."
Underlining the supremacy of parliament, he asserted that the question of deciding between the two is "is in the province of parliament".
Describing the NJAC as a "judicious mix of judiciary, executive and the civil society", Rohatgi said "there is no absolute say here (with judiciary), no absolute say there (executive)" and mocked the contention that NJAC was an "affront" to judicial independence.
Questioning the collegium system, he said: "Experience has shown that everything is not well with existing system", and added that even the petitioner - the Supreme Court Advocate on Record Association - who have challenged the NJAC, favours changing it.
Arguing that the court could not pass an order restraining the government from going ahead with the NJAC, Rohatgi, referring to an earlier constitution bench judgment, said that the court had no power to tell the government to enforce a law and by the same measure, it does not have power inhabiting the government from enforcing a law.
He brushed aside senior counsel Fali Nariman's submission that NJAC Act does not states why it turned its back on the former chief justice M.N. Venkatachaliah's recommendation for a five member National Judicial Commission with three judicial members, saying parliament was not obliged to accept these recommendations.
"Parliament is not answerable to Fali Nariman or M.N. Venkatachaliah. They are not statutes. It was a commission and after 15 years, parliament can take a different view."
The attorney general also contended that if the court decides to refer the matter to a five judges bench, then it should also hold a hearing on the framing of question that would be addressed by the larger bench.
Solicitor General Ranjit Kumar meanwhile told the court that it had no power to stall the proposed notification and it should not exercise its discretionary powers against the government.
"Given the presumption of constitutionality, the will of the legislature should not be stayed or put on hold. System of checks and balances should be acted upon in a balanced way," he said.
Telling the court that the challenge to the constitutional amendment and NJAC Act, 2014 could not be heard, senior counsel and Supreme Court Bar Association president Dushyant Dave said that since the law has not come into force, it can't be challenged.
He said the question that NJAC was violative of the basic structure of the constitution could only be examined in context of the constitutional provisions and not in light of 1993 judgment of the apex court in judges case.
Hearing will continue Thursday.
Police beat up Sachin's biggest fan: Munshi abused, kicked in the police station inaugurated by becoming a celebrity in Muzaffarpur
Former cricketer Sachin Tendulkar's fan Sudhir Kumar was thrashed by a policeman at the Town police station in Muzaffarpur district. In the town police station where Sudhir had been inaugurated as the
Khalistan: Amidst the Khalistan controversy, Foreign Minister Jaishankar said a big thing about the Sikh community, and showed a mirror to Canada.
Indian Foreign Minister S Jaishankar is currently on a tour of America. During an event in Washington DC, he was asked questions about Khalistan, during which he praised the Sikh community and said
Weather Update: Mercury will rise in these areas before Holi, IMD predicts rain and snowfall in hilly areas
The weather started changing before Holi. The heat wave is being witnessed in most of the states across the country. According to the Meteorological Department, the temperature will increase in most
Children were pelted with money in Kanpur: Local leaders and people of the locality distributed money, and provoked them by feeding biryani
During the violence on June 3 in Kanpur, children also pelted stones and bombed. This has been confirmed by the investigation of CCTV footage and viral photo videos. On the orders of the National
Alien Alert: Contact the world of aliens! The mysterious signal coming from space stunned the scientists
Alien News: Many types of claims are made about aliens every day in the world. Sometimes people make such claims, knowing about which even scientists are surprised. Do aliens exist in the universe?
Weather Update: Weather patterns will change again, with fog in Delhi and clouds in UP-Bihar; Know the condition of other states
Weather Update: It is raining in many parts of the country along with snowfall in the mountains. At the same time, after the rain on Sunday in the national capital, the weather appeared clear but
Heath Streak: The news of the death of the former Zimbabwe captain is false, confirmed by Henry Olanga
The news of the death of Zimbabwe's great cricketer Heath Streak turned out to be a rumor when Henry Olanga dismissed it. Earlier, Henry had confirmed the news of his death by tweeting. Now again by
PM Modi said on the death of Shinzo Abe - lost a friend, a day's national mourning
Shinzo Abe passes away: The world has been stunned by the news of the death of former Japanese Prime Minister Shindo Abe after being shot. PM Narendra Modi has expressed grief over his sudden death.
Team India: BCCI can give rest to big players before the World Cup, Shubman Gill's name also included in the list
Team India will tour Ireland after playing two Tests, three ODIs, and five T20s in the West Indies. India had also toured Ireland for a T20I series last year and the India B team under the captaincy
To whom do Islamic countries stand in the Ukraine-Russia crisis?
Muslims constitute one to two percent of Ukraine's population of 4.49 crore. The majority of the population here is Christian. Russia has started military action on eastern Ukraine.