The Supreme Court has put its stamp on the reservation being given to the Economically Weaker Section (EWS). This reservation will be applicable in the future also. A five-judge bench ruled in favor of the EWS reservation by 3-2. Three judges upheld the 103rd amendment to the Constitution for reservation. At the same time, Chief Justice UU Lalit and Justice Ravindra Bhat gave their opinion against this reservation. Know the full verdict, which judges said what, and what does it mean?
Which judges ruled in favor and who in opposition?
Justice JB Pardiwala, Justice Dinesh Maheshwari, and Justice Bela Trivedi ruled in favor of the EWS reservation. These judges considered that this reservation is not against the Constitution, but an opportunity to provide equal opportunities to all. He said that the amendment which has been made regarding reservation is under the intention of the Constitution. At the same time, Chief Justice UU Lalit and Justice Ravindra Bhat gave their opinion against it.
What did Justice Dinesh Maheshwari say?
Justice Dinesh Maheshwari said in favor of the EWS reservation, 'We have taken care of equality. Can economic quota be the only basis for giving economic reservations? The quota on economic grounds is not against the basic spirit of the Constitution. This in no way harms the very essence of reservation.' Justice Maheshwari upheld the 103rd amendment to the Constitution.
What did Justice Bela Trivedi say?
Justice Bela Trivedi also upheld Justice Maheshwari's remarks. He said that I agree with the conclusion of Justice Maheshwari. He said that SC/ST/OBC have already got a reservation. It cannot be included in the general category. The framers of the constitution had talked about keeping the reservation for a limited time, but it continues even after 75 years.
What did Justice Pardiwala say?
Justice JB Pardiwala agreed with the points raised by Justice Maheshwari and Justice Bela and said, "Reservation is not an end, it is a means, and it should not be allowed to become vested interests." He further said, 'Reservation should not be extended indefinitely. This is a way to benefit people on a large scale. That's why I am in favor of the amendment made for the EWS reservation.
Justice Ravindra Bhat expressed dissent
Giving the reservation decision on economic grounds, Justice Ravindra Bhat disagreed. He said, 'A major part of the population belongs to SC/ST/OBC. Many of them are poor. Therefore, the 103rd Amendment is wrong. It will not be right to give reservations above 50 percent. Articles 15(6) and 16(6) should be repealed.
Chief Justice also agreed with Justice Bhat's decision
Chief Justice UU Lalit also opposed reservation on economic grounds. He said that I agree with the decision of Justice Ravindra Bhat. He said, crossing the 50 percent reservation limit is against the basic structure. This is against the basic spirit of the Constitution.
What is the whole matter, understand
The Central Government had made the 103rd amendment in the Constitution to give 10 percent reservation to the economically weaker upper castes. Its validity was challenged in the Supreme Court. The five-judge bench had reserved the verdict on September 27. The five-judge constitution bench comprises Chief Justice UU Lalit, Justices Dinesh Maheshwari, S Ravindra Bhat, Bela M Trivedi, and JB Pardiwala. The marathon hearing in the case lasted for about seven days. In this, the petitioners and (then) Attorney General KK Venugopal and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta made their arguments regarding the EWS quota.
What did the petitioners argue?
The petitioners had argued that the purpose of reservation was the upliftment of the socially discriminated class, if poverty is the basis, then SC-ST-OBC should also get a place in it. The EWS quota is a violation of the 50 percent reservation limit.
What side did the government take?
The government also put forth its stand in the Supreme Court on the claims of the petitioner. It was said by the government that this system is necessary to get equality status to the EWS section. On behalf of the central government, it was said that there is no harm to any other class getting a reservation from this system. The 50% limit that is being said is not a constitutional arrangement, it has come from a decision of the Supreme Court. In such a situation, it would be wrong to say that reservation cannot be given beyond this.
Also Read: Supreme Court: Supreme Court to pronounce verdict on petitions challenging EWS quota in jobs today
Himani Murder Case: 'Sachin was just a pawn, behind the murder...'; U-turn in Himani murder case due to this revelation by mother
Police have disclosed the murder of Congress worker Himani and have named her friend Sachin as the accused. Money transaction is said to be the reason behind the murder, but this theory of police is
Ram Temple: Preparations for Ram Janmabhoomi Pran Pratistha Mahotsav intensified, former Chief Minister of Karnataka will also participate
The date of 22 January 2024 is going to be recorded in the pages of history in Ayodhya. The grand Ram temple is to be consecrated on this day. In such a situation, all preparations have been
Sikkim Flood: There were warnings of Lhonak Lake breaking for years, and many researches and campaigns had said that disaster would come.
Many scientific researches and campaigns published in the last two decades have warned about the breaking of Sikkim's Lhonak Lake. Studies by government and non-government agencies also predicted
Pahalgam Attack: All-party meeting on Pahalgam terror attack today, Attari border closed; bodies of the dead are being sent home.
The central government will hold an all-party meeting on Thursday on the terrorist attack in Pahalgam. Official sources gave this information. He said that Defense Minister Rajnath Singh may chair
Cyclone Michaung: After the devastation caused by Cyclone Michaung in Chennai, schools and colleges remained closed even today, and examinations were also postponed.
Cyclonic storm Michong has now weakened. Before hitting the coast between Nellore and Machilipatnam in Andhra Pradesh on Tuesday, it caused massive devastation in four districts of Tamil Nadu
Know the features of the new launch phone Lava Blaze Next in 5 points, the sale of the phone started on Amazon
Recently the cheapest phone of the Lava brand has been launched Lava Blaze Next. The phone has been launched in 3 bright colors Blue, Green, and Red. If you want a cheap phone with all the smart
Bloody Daddy Ott Release Date: Shahid Kapoor will leave the theater and return to digital, 'Bloody Daddy' released on OTT on this day
Bloody Daddy Ott Release: Kabir Singh Shahid Kapoor of the film world is going to be seen in back to back films in the year 2023. While on one hand he is working with Kriti Sanon in an untitled
Tamil Nadu: Three killed in floods in Tamil Nadu, NDRF busy in rescuing 800 passengers trapped in the train.
The southern districts of Tamil Nadu are facing a flood-like situation these days. It has been raining heavily in these districts for the last three days. Due to this many areas have been submerged.
Tennis: Diya Chitale gives U Mumba second consecutive win, defending champions Chennai Lions defeated in a thrilling match
In Ultimate Table Tennis Season 4, the Mumbai team achieved its second consecutive victory. Mumbai beat defending champions Chennai 8-7 at the Shiv Chhatrapati Sports Complex on Sunday. Young Indian
If there is a war between India and Pakistan… this road of UP will be useful for the army, Rafale and Sukhoi had landed three days before Operation Sindoor.
Just three days before Operation Sindoor, the airstrip on the Ganga Expressway from where the fighter planes of the Indian Air Force took off to express their intentions to Pakistan. Its security has
