The Supreme Court has refused to impose more restrictions on the freedom of speech of ministers, MPs, and MLAs. On Tuesday, a five-judge bench in the Supreme Court said that necessary provisions already exist in Article 19 (2) of the Constitution for this. The court said that for any objectionable statement, only the minister issuing it should be held responsible. Government should not be responsible for this.
In a petition filed in the Supreme Court, there was a demand to make guidelines on freedom of speech for people holding public positions. The matter of fixing the limit of rhetoric for politicians started in 2016 with the rhetoric of Azam Khan, a minister in the Uttar Pradesh government, in the Bulandshahr gang rape case. Azam had called the Bulandshahr gang rape of July 2016 a political conspiracy. Only after this, the matter reached the Supreme Court.
The court said – the minister is responsible for his statement
The five-judge constitution bench was headed by Justice SA Nazeer. At the same time, Justice BR Gavai, Justice AS Bopanna, Justice V Ramasubramaniam, and Justice BV Nagaratna were also involved in this. A five-judge bench said that the government cannot be held responsible for the statement of a minister. The minister is responsible for this. However, Justice Nagaratna's opinion differed from that of the Constitution Bench.
Justice Nagaratna's opinion differs from the four judges
Justice Nagaratna said- Apart from Article 19(2), not much restriction can be imposed on freedom of expression. , However, if a person makes derogatory statements as a minister, then the government can be held responsible for such statements. But, if the statements of ministers are sporadic, and do not align with the stand of the government, then they will be treated as personal remarks.
The Supreme Court reserved the decision on 15 November
The Supreme Court reserved its decision in this matter on 15 November. During this, the court had said that people sitting on public posts should not do such things, which are derogatory to the countrymen. During the hearing, the court said that this behavior is part of our constitutional culture and for this, it is not necessary to frame a code of conduct for people holding public office.
The case started with the Bulandshahr gangrape case
On July 29, 2016, the case of gang rape came to light in Bulandshahr. On this, Azam Khan, who was a minister in the Uttar Pradesh government, made an absurd statement, after which a demand was made to frame guidelines on freedom of speech for people holding public positions.
Delhi Election 2025 Date: Delhi election dates are to be announced today, The Election Commission will hold a press conference at 2 pm
The Election Commission will announce the dates of the assembly elections in the capital, Delhi, today. According to the information received, the Election Commission will hold a press conference at 2
Nagpur Violence: 'Nagpur violence was well planned', CM Fadnavis said in the assembly - will not spare the culprits
Regarding Nagpur violence, Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has said that it seems that this violence was planned. Speaking on the Nagpur issue in the Assembly, CM Fadnavis said that
'Take concrete steps instead of making hollow claims', Rahul Gandhi spoke to Amit Shah; also took information from CM Omar Abdullah.
Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi said on Wednesday that he has spoken to Home Minister Amit Shah, Jammu, and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah, and state Congress President Tariq
G7 Summit: PM Modi will leave for Italy today to attend the G7 Summit; the first foreign visit of his third term
Prime Minister Narendra Modi will leave for Italy today. The three-day G7 summit is starting today in Fasano, Italy. PM Modi will also participate in it. This is the first foreign visit of Modi's new
Atiq Ahmed: Whom Atiq was gesturing before his death, video viral
Mafia Atiq Ahmed, who ruled the world of Jarayam for more than four decades, not only got rich through the power of bullying but also left no stone unturned to make his relatives rich. Be it an
Chaos over the breaking of Ambedkar's statue in Amritsar, CM Mann furious; said- no one will be spared.
Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann on Monday strongly condemned the vandalization of BR Ambedkar's statue in Amritsar and said that no one will be forgiven for this incident. This incident, which
After the CJI, another judge was attacked with a shoe; the court gave its verdict on the attacker.
Recently, a man threw a shoe at CJI BR Gavai in the Supreme Court. This incident sparked a new debate in the country. Now, about a week after this incident, a similar incident has come to light in
Republic Day 2025: Who will be the state guest on Republic Day? Who accepted PM Narendra Modi's invitation?
This time on the occasion of Republic Day, Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto will be the state guest of India. The Ministry of External Affairs has said that the President of Indonesia has
Trump will impose a 50% tariff on India from today. How much will be the loss? What is the Modi government's plan?
Even after the announcement of imposing a 50 percent duty on India, the government will have to pay the price for not bowing down to the US conditions from Wednesday. From August 27, a 50 percent duty
World Cup 2023: Afghanistan captain especially thanked Indian fans after defeating Sri Lanka
Afghanistan captain Hashmatullah Shahidi on Monday thanked the Indian fans after defeating Sri Lanka by seven wickets with 28 balls to spare in the 30th match of the World Cup 2023.
