The Supreme Court has refused to impose more restrictions on the freedom of speech of ministers, MPs, and MLAs. On Tuesday, a five-judge bench in the Supreme Court said that necessary provisions already exist in Article 19 (2) of the Constitution for this. The court said that for any objectionable statement, only the minister issuing it should be held responsible. Government should not be responsible for this.
In a petition filed in the Supreme Court, there was a demand to make guidelines on freedom of speech for people holding public positions. The matter of fixing the limit of rhetoric for politicians started in 2016 with the rhetoric of Azam Khan, a minister in the Uttar Pradesh government, in the Bulandshahr gang rape case. Azam had called the Bulandshahr gang rape of July 2016 a political conspiracy. Only after this, the matter reached the Supreme Court.
The court said – the minister is responsible for his statement
The five-judge constitution bench was headed by Justice SA Nazeer. At the same time, Justice BR Gavai, Justice AS Bopanna, Justice V Ramasubramaniam, and Justice BV Nagaratna were also involved in this. A five-judge bench said that the government cannot be held responsible for the statement of a minister. The minister is responsible for this. However, Justice Nagaratna's opinion differed from that of the Constitution Bench.
Justice Nagaratna's opinion differs from the four judges
Justice Nagaratna said- Apart from Article 19(2), not much restriction can be imposed on freedom of expression. , However, if a person makes derogatory statements as a minister, then the government can be held responsible for such statements. But, if the statements of ministers are sporadic, and do not align with the stand of the government, then they will be treated as personal remarks.
The Supreme Court reserved the decision on 15 November
The Supreme Court reserved its decision in this matter on 15 November. During this, the court had said that people sitting on public posts should not do such things, which are derogatory to the countrymen. During the hearing, the court said that this behavior is part of our constitutional culture and for this, it is not necessary to frame a code of conduct for people holding public office.
The case started with the Bulandshahr gangrape case
On July 29, 2016, the case of gang rape came to light in Bulandshahr. On this, Azam Khan, who was a minister in the Uttar Pradesh government, made an absurd statement, after which a demand was made to frame guidelines on freedom of speech for people holding public positions.
Will a world war start today? Iran can attack Israel, Netanyahu is also ready after America's warning
Iran can attack Israel Iran is furious after the killing of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh. Iran has spoken of taking revenge after Israel's attacks on its soil and it can target Israel today itself.
Dunki Advance Booking: 'Dunki' rang in booking, figure crossed 4 crores, see the collection
Dunki Advance Booking: Shah Rukh Khan is ready to make a splash this year with the film 'Dunki'. After 'Pathan' and 'Jawaan', fans are excited to see him in a comedy role in 'Danky'. One example of
There will be a separate board for Bohra-Agakhani: The face of the Waqf Council will change, the Waqf Bill can be sent to the Select Committee today
To curb the unlimited powers given to the Waqf Board and for better management and transparency, the government may introduce two bills in the Lok Sabha on Thursday. Through the first bill, the
ODI WC 2023: 'Pakistan has made an agreement, cannot back down'; ICC's response to PCB's statement about coming to India
After the schedule of the ODI World Cup was decided, the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) started reluctantly. He said in a statement on Tuesday that he has not received the No Objection Certificate (NOC)
Opposition On GST: 'Walked on the wrong path for eight years, now took a U-turn', opposition slammed the Centre on GST
The opposition is constantly trying to corner the BJP over the GST reform. Today, many big Congress leaders and TMC MP Mahua Moitra put forth their views on this issue. Some called this decision a
IND vs ENG: Devdutt Padikkal got a chance to debut in Dharamshala and the old record of Indian cricket was broken after 24 years.
The last match of the five-match Test series between India and England (IND vs ENG 5th Test) is being played in Dharamshala. In this match, the England team won the toss and decided to bat first. The
Himachal Pradesh: Natural disaster wreaks havoc in Himachal, the rescue of 780 people from flood-affected areas in Kangra
Natural calamity has created havoc in Himachal Pradesh. As many as 1,220 roads were closed in Mandi, Shimla, Kullu, district Sirmaur and other affected areas. Due to this, more than two thousand
Weather changes due to drizzle in Delhi-NCR, how will the weather be today in other states, including UP-Bihar?
The monsoon has begun to withdraw from North India. For the past few days, several states, including Delhi-NCR, have experienced humid heat. However, the weather may change in many places today. The
Amaal Malik plays another 'game' with Tanya Mittal, a new twist on the sweater in 'Bigg Boss 19'
Every day, the reality show Bigg Boss 19 sees a new drama unfold. Sometimes it's a fight over household chores, sometimes it's a debate about relationship complexities, but this time things are a
T20 World Cup 2026: 'India will never win', your blood will boil after listening to the words of a former selector, who made a shocking claim
Former Indian chief selector Krishnamachari Srikkanth has made a big statement about the Indian team in the T20 World Cup 2026. He has raised questions on the selection policy of the Indian team
