New Delhi, Feb 11 (IANS) The Supreme Court Wednesday rejected a plea seeking to quash appointment of Shashi Kant Sharma as the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) on the grounds of conflict of interest.
The plea stated that as country's auditor Sharma would be judging a number of defence deals that were concluded or cleared when he was defence secretary.
The apex court bench of Chief Justice H.L. Dattu, Justice A.K. Sikri and Justice Arun Mishra rejected the plea, as Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi cited the constitutional provisions prescribing the CAG's appointment by the President on the aid and advice of the council of ministers.
Rohatgi told the court that under the constitution the CAG's appointment rested with the government and the constitution has left it to the government to aid and advise the President on the appointment of the CAG and the court could not interfere in it.
The court observed that the attorney general was skirting the issue.
It told Rohatgi that counsel Prashant Bhushan, appearing for the petitioners, was contending that the way court had interpreted the provisions of the constitution to put in place the collegium system for the appointment of judges and free it from executive interference, similarly, court should interpret constitutional provisions for the appointment of CAG to make it more transparent and non-arbitrary.
At this, the attorney general told the court that the interpretation of the constitution in the second judges case in 1992 creating the collegium system for the judges' appointment was incorrect.
"One day, we will have to debate whether it (creating collegium system) was right or wrong. I submit it was wrong. That was wrong assessment of the constitution. There was no audit (of the performance of the judges)," Rohatgi told the court.
"How is it that judges appointed after 1990s (by collegium system) were better and those appointed from 1952 onwards were not up to the mark?"
Addressing the court, Bhushan told the court there has to be transparent procedure for CAG's appointment.
"This is an important position. Why should not be there some system and procedure for the appointment of CAG. People should know that such a position is going to be filled up so that they can make recommendations."
"If you demonstrate that this person (to be appointed as CAG) suffers from disability before the court of law , then this court can certainly say that the appointing authority should have taken these disabilities into account at the time of making appointment," court told Bhushan.
Former Chief Election Commissioner N. Gopalaswami, former Naval chiefs Admiral (retd.) R.H. Tahiliani and Admiral (retd.) L. Ramdas, three former secretaries to the government Kamal Kantt Jaswal, Ramaswamy R. Iyer and E.A.S. Sarma, a former IAS officer and Army officer M.G. Devasahayam, former deputy CAG B.P. Mathur and former Indian Audit and Accounts Service officer S. Krishnan have moved the PIL seeking a writ of quo warrant to set aside the appointment of Sharma as CAG.
Pune Car Accident: After the father and grandfather, the mother was also caught by the police while trying to save the minor; she committed this big crime
A new twist has emerged in the Pune Porsche car accident. Pune Police has arrested the teenager's mother in the Porsche car accident case. It has been confirmed in the case that the teenager's blood
US Abortion Laws: Effect of Supreme Court's decision in America, increased sales of contraceptive emergency pills
After the Supreme Court in the US overturned its 49-year-old decision that legalized abortion, the demand for birth control pills in the country has seen a huge increase. Because of this, Amazon and
Billionaires List: Gautam Adani slipped to number 25 in the list of the rich, the group's market cap below $ 100 billion
The wealth of Gautam Adani, head of the Adani Group, which is involved in the business from ports to power, has come down to $ 50 billion. According to the data of the Bloomberg Billionaire Index on
US Capitol Riot: Two years of US Capitol violence, Biden said- 'American democracy was attacked'
Two years have passed since the attack on the US Parliament. Regarding the Capitol Hill violence (US Capitol Riot), US President Joe Biden said that two years ago i.e. on January 6, 2021, the
One Nation One Election: 'One country one election is not undemocratic', Law Ministry listed the benefits of simultaneous elections to the joint committee
The Union Law Ministry has praised the 'One Nation, One Election' Bill. The ministry has told the Joint Committee of Parliament considering 'One Nation-One Election' that holding simultaneous
Final Bihar voting update: Total voter turnout 66.91%, 71.6% women and 68.2% men cast their votes
In the 2025 Bihar Assembly elections, voters created history. For the first time since India's independence, a record 66.91 percent cast their ballots. In the first phase, on November 6th, voter
Budget 2024-25: Startups hope to overcome funding shortages, get tax concessions and boost R&D
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman made several announcements for startups in the interim budget presented in February. The period for setting up a startup for tax exemption was extended to March 31,
India-Pakistan clash every year: PCB President Rameez Raja will present the proposal before the ICC, know what is the neighbor's plan
Fans of both countries eagerly wait to watch the cricket match between India and Pakistan. Due to diplomatic relations between India and Pakistan, no series is played between the two. Both the teams
Uncontrollable speed of Corona in China, heaps of dead bodies on cremation grounds, experts said – millions of people may die
After the relaxation of Covid-19 restrictions, there has been a spurt in the cases of Corona Virus in China. Epidemiologist Eric Feigl-Ding said that hospitals in China were completely overwhelmed.
Congress President Election: Rahul will not contest for the post of Congress President! Will there be a contest between Gehlot and Tharoor?
The suspense on who will be the next president of Congress will end in a few days. There is little hope of Rahul Gandhi contesting the elections. In such a situation, the new President of Congress
