New Delhi, Feb 11 (IANS) The Supreme Court Wednesday said it will examine whether the Competition Commission of India had the jurisdiction to entertain the plea by flat owners in three DLF residential complexes in Gurgaon who alleged that the real estate giant was exploiting its dominant position on conditions for providing services.
The bench of Justice Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya and Justice N.V. Ramana, while making distinction between the "rendering of services" and "imposing the conditions of services", said they would examine the issue in the light of section 4(2)(a)(1) of the Competition Act, 2002.
The court said if the matter was "rendering of services", then it would go before the consumer forum.
"Satisfaction with the services provided can be a matter of consumer court," it said.
Rendering services may not come under the Competition Act, "but imposing the conditions of services may be so whether they are arbitrary, unfair or discriminatory", the court said, as it directed the hearing of the matter for Feb 18.
Section 4 of the Competition Act prohibits the abuse of dominant position and section 4(2)(a)(1) says there shall be an abuse of dominant position if an enterprise or a group directly or indirectly, imposes unfair or discriminatory condition in purchase or sale of goods or service.
The court said this while hearing a petition by DLF challenging imposition of Rs.630 crore penalty by the CCI for allegedly exploiting its dominant position to the disadvantage of its customers in three projects in Gurgaon.
DLF has assailed the CCI order of Aug 12, 2011, which was sustained by the COMPAT in 2013, saying that the commission could not have imposed penalty based on the three year average of the entire turnover of DLF's real estate operations in the country.
The real estate giant contended that the penalty should have been restricted to Rs.1,100 crore - the sale price of three housing complexes.
DLF has also challenged the jurisdiction of CCI in entertaining the pleas by the aggrieved flat owners.
The CCI has taken a position that DLF used its dominant position to the disadvantage of the flat allotees.
"It is an exploitation of disadvantaged customers who were trapped," CCI had told the court.
The association of flat owners and individual flat owners too have moved the apex court.
BSES seeks Payments of Rs.14,500 Crore outstanding dues
New Delhi, Feb 18 (IANS) Reliance owned discoms BSES Rajdhani and Yamuna Wednesday told the Supreme Court that if its existing outstanding dues which stand at Rs. 14,500 crores were not paid by
Mumbai Rainfall Alert: Warning of heavy rain in many districts of Maharashtra including Mumbai, schools will remain closed
Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde has declared holidays for schools given the rain alert by the Meteorological Department in Mumbai and neighboring districts. It has been raining continuously
Tripura: President Draupadi Murmu will visit Tripura on Wednesday on a two-day visit
President Draupadi Murmu is coming on a two-day visit to Tripura on Wednesday. During this, she will inaugurate several development projects. This is Murmu's first visit to the Northeast after
Heavy road accident in Bhagalpur, 9 migrant laborers killed in bus-truck collision
Bhagalpur
Parliament: Ban on dharna, hunger strike in Parliament premises! Congress's taunt - 'New work of Vishwaguru...'
Has there been a ban on picketing and demonstrations on the Parliament premises now? Congress has made this claim while sharing a bulletin of a Parliament Secretariat. This order has angered the
GSEB 12th Result: How many students were successful in Gujarat Board 12th result, what was the success percentage, read here
GSEB 12th Result: Gujarat Secondary and Higher Secondary Education Board (GSEB) has declared the results of the GSEB HSC general stream examination i.e. Faculty of Arts and Commerce (Commerce). The
Russia-Ukraine War: Russian attack on Ukraine continues for the ninth consecutive day, another Indian student became the victim of the attack
Today is the ninth day of the war between Russia and Ukraine. Russian military attack on Ukraine is not taking the name of stopping. Meanwhile, an Indian student had to be hospitalized after being
Lowest active cases of corona in the country in 200 days, 20 thousand new cases came in the last 24 hours
The situation of the corona epidemic in the country is continuously improving. Corona cases have reduced once again across the country. In the last 24 hours, about 20 thousand new cases of corona have
ICC ODI Rankings: India Overtakes Pakistan, Ranks 3rd In ICC ODI Rankings
Team India has moved to third place in the latest ICC rankings with a spectacular 10-wicket win in the first match of the ODI series against England. With this, India has left Pakistan behind. Now
Bigg Boss OTT 2: Jia Shankar upset after seeing the bonding of Manisha Rani and her father, the actress cried remembering the family
Bigg Boss OTT Season 2 is gaining immense popularity among viewers. Seeing the demand for the show, the makers extended it by two weeks. Apart from this, social media influencers like Abhishek Malhan
