New Delhi, March 24 (IANS) The Supreme Court, which on Tuesday struck down Section 66 A of the Information Technology Act, said expressions such as "grossly offensive" or "menacing" in it were vague and nebulous in meaning, and there were no manageable standards by which a person can be held to have committed an offence.
"Quite apart from this, as has been pointed out above, every expression used is nebulous in meaning. What may be offensive to one may not be offensive to another. What may cause annoyance or inconvenience to one may not cause annoyance or inconvenience to another," said a bench of Justice J. Chelameswar and Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman in their judgment.
The court said that use of word "persistently" for repeated sending of message is "completely imprecise", and wondered what would constitute "persistently" - sending a message three times or eight times before it could be described as persistent.
"There is no demarcating line conveyed by any of these expressions - and that is what renders the section unconstitutionally vague," the verdict said.
Not accepting the government's contention that expressions used in the section could be incapable of any precise definition but not constitutionally vulnerable due to this, the court noted the two opposing conclusions that could be reached in dealing with vague and nebulous expressions, citing two British judgments where on the same facts, judges arrived at opposite decisions.
"If judicially trained minds can come to diametrically opposite conclusions on the same set of facts, it is obvious that expressions such as 'grossly offensive' or 'menacing' are so vague that there is no manageable standard by which a person can be said to have committed an offence or not to have committed an offence," it held, terming the expressions used in Section 66A "completely open-ended and undefined".
None of the expressions used in Section 66A - not even "criminal intimidation" with the act's definition clause - not saying that the words and expressions defined in the Indian Penal Code will apply here.
Thus, "authorities who are to enforce Section 66A have absolutely no manageable standard by which to book a person for an offence under Section 66A".
"This being the case, having regard also to the two English precedents, it is clear that Section 66A is unconstitutionally vague," the verdict said.
'Maro Mujhe Maro' fan is back: Viral fan's new video surfaced ahead of Indo-Pak match
The fever of the match between India and Pakistan to be played on October 24 is going up in everyone's head. Players are busy in their preparations and fans are eagerly waiting for it. Meanwhile, the
Modi to address farmers in next 'Mann ki Baat'
New Delhi, March 18 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi will address farmers in his next "Mann Ki Baat" address that will be aired on March 22 on All India Radio, an official communique said on
Monkeypox: Competition between Serum and Bharat Biotech to make monkeypox vaccine
Like Corona, now there is a competition between two big famous companies in the country regarding the monkeypox vaccine. Last time, Hyderabad-based Bharat Biotech Company was at the forefront to make
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Corona positive, his minister was infected two days ago
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chauhan has left Corona positive. Let us tell you that two days ago Madhya Pradesh Cooperative Minister Arvind Singh Bhadoria was found to be Corona
Train Accident: Relief work completed, operations will resume on the railway track by 4 pm
The death toll in the train accident in Vijayanagaram, Andhra Pradesh has reached 13 so far. East Coast Railway CPRO Biswajit Sahu said that relief and rescue operations have been completed. Now the
United Nations: Ukraine crisis was being discussed, Pakistan raised the issue of Kashmir, and India lashed out fiercely
Pakistan's nefarious act has once again come to the fore in the United Nations General Assembly and for this, India has once again lashed out. The issue of the Ukraine-Russia war was going on in the
V.K. Singh says tweets directed at media, denies offer to resign
New Delhi, March 24 (IANS) Facing flak over his tweets after attending the Pakistan Day function, Minister of State for External Affairs Gen. (retd) V.K. Singh on Tuesday said the messages were
Modi government Said, Corona vaccine will give crores of Indians
The government of India plans to bring 40-50 crore corona vaccine for 20-25 crore Indians by July 2021. Union Health Minister Harsh Vardhan has given this information on Sunday.
NJAC Act is still-born: Nariman tells SC
New Delhi, March 19 (IANS) The Supreme Court was told on Thursday that the National Judicial Appointment Commission Act, 2014 was a still-born law.Pointing out that the Constitution (Ninety-ninth
China, who was shocked by Taiwan and Pentagon relations, said- will control Taiwan if needed
China strongly criticized the visit to Taiwan by a senior Pentagon official and confirmed that Taiwan had approved the Pentagon for the supply of military equipment to the Pentagon and a unit of