New Delhi, March 24 (IANS) The Supreme Court, which on Tuesday struck down Section 66 A of the Information Technology Act, said expressions such as "grossly offensive" or "menacing" in it were vague and nebulous in meaning, and there were no manageable standards by which a person can be held to have committed an offence.
"Quite apart from this, as has been pointed out above, every expression used is nebulous in meaning. What may be offensive to one may not be offensive to another. What may cause annoyance or inconvenience to one may not cause annoyance or inconvenience to another," said a bench of Justice J. Chelameswar and Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman in their judgment.
The court said that use of word "persistently" for repeated sending of message is "completely imprecise", and wondered what would constitute "persistently" - sending a message three times or eight times before it could be described as persistent.
"There is no demarcating line conveyed by any of these expressions - and that is what renders the section unconstitutionally vague," the verdict said.
Not accepting the government's contention that expressions used in the section could be incapable of any precise definition but not constitutionally vulnerable due to this, the court noted the two opposing conclusions that could be reached in dealing with vague and nebulous expressions, citing two British judgments where on the same facts, judges arrived at opposite decisions.
"If judicially trained minds can come to diametrically opposite conclusions on the same set of facts, it is obvious that expressions such as 'grossly offensive' or 'menacing' are so vague that there is no manageable standard by which a person can be said to have committed an offence or not to have committed an offence," it held, terming the expressions used in Section 66A "completely open-ended and undefined".
None of the expressions used in Section 66A - not even "criminal intimidation" with the act's definition clause - not saying that the words and expressions defined in the Indian Penal Code will apply here.
Thus, "authorities who are to enforce Section 66A have absolutely no manageable standard by which to book a person for an offence under Section 66A".
"This being the case, having regard also to the two English precedents, it is clear that Section 66A is unconstitutionally vague," the verdict said.
'India's situation much better than China', former AIIMS chief Randeep Guleria responds amid outcry in China
Coronavirus Update 21 Dec because of the speed of corona in many countries of the world including China, the government has also become alert. Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya reviewed the
Missile case: Rajnath made a statement, Pakistan spoke to Germany, China and America also commented
Defense Minister Rajnath Singh made a statement in Parliament on Tuesday on the issue of a missile that accidentally fell into Pakistan's territory on March 9 from India. On the other hand, Pakistan's
Some relief from inflation: Mustard and refined oil became cheaper by Rs 15, Mother Dairy announced
Dhara, a brand that sells edible oil, is going to cut the price of its mustard and refined oil by Rs 15. This help is a dairy company. Which has announced to reduce the prices of mustard, soybean, and
Urvashi Rautela Birthday: Urvashi Rautela has won the most beauty titles, modeling opened the way to acting
Bollywood actress Urvashi Rautela is known more for her glamour and beauty than her acting. Today Urvashi is celebrating her 31st birthday. The actress also gives fashion goals from time to time with
India expressed concern over the closure of girls' education in Afghanistan, the world community also criticized a large scale
India has also expressed concern over reports of the Taliban in Afghanistan stopping the admission of girls to universities there. India has said that India has always supported the education of women
Intercontinental Cup Football: India's match with Vanuatu in Intercontinental Cup football, eyes on final ticket
The Indian team will take on Vanuatu in the four-nation Intercontinental Cup football on Monday but will be eyeing a place in the final of the tournament. India beat Mongolia 2-0 in their first match
Bengal SSC Scam: Admit card and appointment letter received from Partha Chatterjee's house, ED's revelations will increase the minister's troubles
West Bengal SSC Scam: The problems of West Bengal Minister Partha Chatterjee are increasing. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) claims to have seized several admit cards, appointment letters, and
Amazon Deal: After buying this great Samsung phone in-camera, you will forget the iPhone!
Amazon Discount Samsung Galaxy S21: Main Triple Rear Camera with 30X Space Zoom and 36MP Selfie Camera. Samsung Galaxy S21 is a style statement in itself because of its look and camera. The colors of
Positivity rate crosses 19% in 2 states of the country: 16,281 new corona patients found; 13 lakh people got booster dose as soon as it became free
Corona cases are increasing continuously in the country. On the previous day, 16,281 new corona patients appeared and 28 patients died. The news of relief is that the number of patients recovering
Net Worth: Elon Musk lost as much as Mukesh Ambani earned in his entire life in a single year, know the figures
Elon Musk, the world's richest person who recently took over Twitter, is also number one in terms of losing wealth. At present, he has achieved this position by overtaking Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg.
