Kolkata, March 12 (IANS) A top American researcher has questioned the scientific accuracy of environmental impact assessment reports for India's hydropower projects, criticising the process behind environmental clearances as being "manipulative".
Kelly D. Alley, a professor of anthropology, Auburn University, U.S. has carried out research in northern India for over twenty years, focusing on public culture and environmental issues.
"I took two sets of hydropower cases that are important projects -the Subansiri and Dibang projects in north east India.
"My paper questions the EIA and the processes... how those (environmental) clearances are obtained. Basically the clearance process is corrupt in terms of rent-seeking. I wanted to highlight the clearance processes are manipulated so that in this dangerous situation we should do a better job," Alley told IANS here, after the study was released.
Alley is the author of books such as 'On the Banks of the Ganga: When Wastewater Meets a Sacred River' that explores Hindu interpretations of the sacred river Ganga in the light of environmental problems.
Some of her other notable publications include 'Water Wealth and Energy in the Indian Himalayas' and 'The Developments, Policies and Assessments of Hydropower in the Ganga River Basin' among others, a result of her work in the Brahmaputra basin and in Varanasi.
She was in the city as part of a delegation for the two-day 'Building Pan Asian Connectivity' conference. Alley released her paper titled 'Challenges for hydropower governance in Brahmaputra basin: Informality, Documentality and Citizen Mandamus' which will be part of a book and will be put in the public domain soon.
"I have shown some of the issues involved in clearing the projects such as forest, environmental clearances and the processes... the steps that a company would have to go through to get it approved and cleared for construction.
"It's not a completely scientific process and many people have questioned the quality of environmental impact assessments (EIA)," she said on Wednesday.
Citing the example of the devastating 2014 Uttarakhand floods and glacial lake outburst in Kedarnath, Alley said the way ahead is to incorporate scientific methods to plan sites of dams.
"When you have so much rain and have it mixed with this glacial melt, it just puts a lot of pressure on the dam and you have rocks and boulders getting shoved down the river bed... it's going to ruin the dam and create blockages," she explained.
To counter the potential hazards, the researcher stressed that 'lot of good science and clean science (not politically motivated) has to go into figuring out how to site dams properly and what are the best locations ecologically, in terms of water cycle for people etc."
"It all comes back to the regulatory process," she pointed out.
The other aspect, according to Alley, is to focus on climate-friendly infrastructure.
"You have the condition of more extreme floods happening. So you have to make sure that whatever infrastructure you built, it can somehow adapt to those conditions and you need some good science, engineers who are thinking about infrastructure adaptable to climate change etc.," she added.
What is the meaning of what Jaishankar said in relations with China?
Indian External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said on Saturday at the Munich Security Conference that the relations between the two countries are going through the most difficult phase right now after
Taliban leader Mullah Baradar said - there was no intention to kill Ashraf Ghani
Afghan Deputy Prime Minister Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar has said the Taliban had no intention of killing former President Ashraf Ghani.
KP Sharma Oli said- Lord Ram was Nepali, even the real Ayodhya was not in India, it was a small village close to Kathmandu
Kathmandu Nepal has started another propaganda amid the border dispute. Nepal's Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli has stated that Lord Ram was a Nepali, not an Indian. He also said that the real Ayodhya is
IPL: Kolkata Knight Riders appointed Chandrakant Pandit as the new coach of the team, replacing Brendon McCullum
IPL franchise Kolkata Knight Riders (KKR) on Thursday appointed Chandrakant Pandit as its new head coach. Pandit, who has had a successful coaching career with several domestic teams, recently coached
Big accident: debris of SpaceX rocket fell in the field, launched on March 4
Last month, the SpaceX rocket, abandoned from the US, succumbed to the accident. A large part of the rocket fell into a farm in Washington. However, no one was killed during this period. The team of
More disasters will come if developed countries do not fulfill their environmental promises: External Affairs Minister Jaishankar
On the environmental crisis, External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar said that countries responsible for global warming need to come forward and stop lying to the world. He warned that as it becomes
Pakistan Politics: ...then civil war will break out in Pakistan, why did former PM Imran Khan say so?
Pakistan Politics: Pakistan's deposed Prime Minister Imran Khan has warned that the country will plunge into civil war if new elections are not announced. According to the 'Dawn' newspaper, in an
In 24 hours, 96792 cases of infection were found and 87778 people recovered, 1175 people died; 52.12 lakh cases so far
In 24 hours 96792 patients of Corona were found in the country and 87778 people were recovered. With this, the number of patients has increased to 52 lakh 12 thousand 686. At the same time, 41 lakh 9
PAK vs AUS: Australia has not lost any semi-final against Pakistan, will Babar Azam be able to change another history?
The teams of Pakistan and Australia will face each other in the second semi-final of the T20 World Cup. This will be Pakistan's fifth and Australia's fourth semi-final match. These two teams have met
If there was a nuclear war between Russia and America, how many lakh people would have died in the first hour? Scientists warn
The ongoing war between Ukraine and Russia has completed 7 months. In these 7 months, the Russian army has destroyed many big cities in Ukraine. Till now lakhs of soldiers from both countries have
