New Delhi, March 25 (IANS) The government on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that Indian army's response during Kargil war was sluggish as it sought and obtained a stay of the Armed Forces Tribunal's order quashing the 2009 policy to have a combat unit commanded by a colonel at the age of 37 years.
As a bench of Justice T.S.Thakur, Justice R. Banumathi and Justice Amitava Roy stayed the tribunal's March 2, 2015 order quashing the 2009 policy under which newly-created 750 posts of colonels were not disbursed across the army on pro rata basis, Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi told the court that the response in Kargil war was "sluggish".
Telling the court that the policy of giving the command of a combat unit to a colonel at the age of 37 followed an examination of why the army's response in the conflict was "sluggish", he said it was found that while an indian army combat unit was being commanded by a colonel aged 41, his counterparts in the Pakistani and Chinese army were aged 37 years.
The AFT order was coming in the way of promotion policy in the army reducing the age of a colonel to 37 years, he said.
The tribunal quashed the January 21, 2009 policy which weighed in favour of infantry, mechanised infantry and armoured corps insofar the 750 newly-created posts of colonels were concerned, saying that it was violative of the constitution's article 14 (equality before law).
The government move had followed the recommendations of Ajay Vikram Singh Committee, which besides other things, had investigated the army's "sluggish" response.
The government had created 1,500 additional posts of colonel - 750 in 2004 and another 750 in 2009 - a larger chunk of which was to go to these three arms for a better age profile of the command structure.
Rohatgi said that the 750 posts created in 2004 for improving the age profile of combat units had been mistakenly disbursed across the army on a pro rata basis, but since this did not achieve the desired objective, a pro rata distribution of another 750 posts was not followed in 2009.
Besides improving the age profile, the additional posts of colonel were needed to accommodate these officers after they exited combat command as in the army hierarchy's pyramid, not everyone could be be promoted to brigadier.
Having some reservations on Rohatgi's stand, the court wondered how could pro rata disbursal of the posts would not favour combat units as it would be on the basis of their respective strengths and these were in a much larger number.
"You can't affords to have disgruntled, dissatisfied and frustrated officers in other wings of army," it said.
Rohatgi however said that if the tribunal's order was to be implemented then the entire policy will have to be unscrambled.
Appearing for the officers who had approached the tribunal, counsel Meenakshi Lekhi contested Rohatgi's assertions, saying that A.V. Singh Committee report did not only talk about the combat units but of a larger age profile at brigade level.
Senior counsel Shekhar Naphade, appearing for another set of aggrieved officers, said that 12 Lt.Generals have opposed the policy, but Rohatgi countered that they were out of 84 but had acknowledged policy decisions rested with the government.
The tribunal order said that government would create supernumerary posts to accommodate Lt. Col. P.K.Choudhary and other officers denied promotion on the basis of quashed policy subject to merit.
ABP Shikhar Sammelan: Saugata Roy said - Jai Shri Ram 'No Bengalis' slogan, we say 'Jai Maa Durga'
ABP Shikhar Sammelan: At the ABP News program summit on West Bengal elections, senior Trinamool Congress leader and MP Saugat Roy said that TMC has never had any problem with Jai Shri Ram's slogan.
China Flood: Outcry due to heavy rains in China, record of 140 years was broken; 21 people died
Rain in China has broken the record of 140 years. In the last five days, 744.8 mm or 29.3 inches of rain has been recorded in Beijing. These rains are being caused by Typhoon Doksuri. Earlier in 1891,
China Coronavirus: Crowd of people at railway stations and airports, fear of this is troubling experts
Coronavirus in China: Coronavirus has caused widespread devastation in China. Despite the dire situation, the government has resumed air and rail services. Railway stations and airports in China's
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's government denied the news of negotiating with Taliban, said - there will be no compromise with security
Pakistan's Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government on Thursday categorically denied reports of any agreement with Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP). The government asked the Taliban leadership to withdraw its
Government inaction on Corona vaccine, Taskforce from procurement to vaccination
The government has intensified preparations to acquire the vaccine, which is considered to be the most effective weapon against Corona and to reach it to the people. The government has formed a task
Salaar: Prabhas starrer 'Salaar' dominates the box office, earned Rs 150 crore in Hindi alone
Leaving behind 'KGF 1', 'Bahubali 1' and 'Pushpa 1', Hombale Films' film 'Salaar', directed by Prashant Neel, has proved to be one of the most successful pan India films of last year. The film has
Omicron's new sub-variant found for the first time in the country: WHO said - we are monitoring; Corona cases increased by 30% in the world
For the first time in the country, a new sub-variant of the corona new variant Omicron has been detected, named BA.2.75. The World Health Organization (WHO) gave this information. WHO Director-General
IFFI jury head called The Kashmir Files a vulgar and propaganda film, Anupam Kher and Ashok Pandit protested
Vivek Agnihotri's film The Kashmir Files, which is one of the highest-grossing films of the year, has once again come into the limelight. This time the film is facing criticism from big platforms like
Conspiracy to shake Punjab failed: Large consignment of arms from Pakistan, 22 pistols, 44 magazines, and heroin recovered
The Pakistani conspiracy to shake Punjab has been foiled on Wednesday. Punjab Police and BSF have recovered a huge cache of arms in the Khemkaran area of Tarn Taran district near the
Meta Layoffs: Layoffs again in Meta from today! Know which employees the social media company is preparing to throw out
The retrenchment of employees of Meta in India can start from today i.e. Wednesday. At least two employees of the social media giant in India have indicated this. Reports from several international