Monday is the fifth day of the demonstration of farmers on the border of Delhi, the capital of India.
Farmers, who are traveling from Punjab Haryana Uttar Pradesh towards Delhi, are opposing three agricultural laws made by the Central Government recently.
According to the All India Farmer Sangharsh Coordination Committee, one of their important demands is, "Government should declare purchases at a price below the Minimum Support Price (MSP) a crime and the government purchases on MSP remain in force."
The Prime Minister himself has tweeted on the MSP saying, "I have said this before and once again I say, the system of MSP will continue, Government procurement will continue. We are here to serve our farmers. We help the donors We will make every effort and ensure a better life for his future generations. "
His tweet is from 20 September 2020.
But the government is not ready to write this in the bill. The government argues that even in its earlier laws, there was no such thing in writing. Therefore, it has not been included in the new bill.
But is it so easy, as is being argued?
Government purchases on MSP are ongoing and declaring the purchase of crops at less than that is a crime, which is not as easy as farmer organizations are feeling.
Why is it difficult for the government to do this?
Before knowing this, it is important to know what MSP is and how it is fixed.
What is MSP?
To protect the interests of farmers, a system of minimum support price (MSP) has been implemented in the country. Even if the price of crops falls according to the market, even then the Central Government buys the crop from the farmers only at the fixed minimum support price so that the farmers can be saved from harm.
The MSP of a crop is the same in the whole country. The Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India, determines the MSP based on the recommendations of the Commission for Agricultural Costs and Prices (Commission for Agriculture Costs and Prices CACP). Under this, 23 crops are being purchased right now.
These 23 crops include crops like paddy, wheat, jowar, millet, maize, moong, groundnut, soybean, sesame, and cotton.
According to an estimate, only 6 percent of the farmers in the country get MSP, of which the maximum number of farmers are from Punjab Haryana. And because of this, opposition to the new bill is also happening more in these areas.
What has changed from the agricultural law so far?
Former Agriculture Secretary of the Government of India Siraj Hussain says that there are some reasons behind the concern of farmers about MSP. The government has not yet issued any such order in writing that government procurement of crops will continue. Whatever is happening till now is verbal. This is one reason for the growing concern of farmers after the new agricultural law.
The thing to note here is that the government procurement will continue, its order is not to come from the Ministry of Agriculture but the Ministry of Food Processing Industries.
The second reason is not to give the Rural Infrastructure Development Fund to the state governments. The central government used to give this fund of three percent to the state governments every year. But this year the central government has refused to give this fund. This fund was used to build rural infrastructure (including agricultural facilities).
After the formation of the new agricultural law, these two important changes are visible to the farmers.
Reason 1: How will the quality standards of crops be determined?
Siraj Hussain says that if the provision of purchase on MSP is added to the law then how will the law be followed? MSP is always for a 'Fair Average Quality'. That is, the minimum support price will be given only if there is a fixed quality of the crop. Now whether a crop fits the quality standards or not, how will it be decided?
What will happen to the crop that will not meet those standards?
In such a situation, if the government also incorporates the demand of farmers in the law, then it will be difficult to implement the law.
Reason 2: Less likely government purchases in the future
Regarding the second reason, Siraj Hussain says that several committees have recommended to the government that the government should reduce the purchase of wheat and paddy. In this regard, the report of the Shanta Kumar Committee to NITI Aayog is with the government.
The government is also working under this objective. This purchase is going to reduce in the coming days. This fear is also haunting the farmers.
In such a situation, if the government will buy the crop or not, then how much, and when it will not be bought, if it is not fixed, then how can the MSP talk in writing in law?
RS Ghuman is a professor at the Center for Research in Rural and Industrial Development, Chandigarh. They have a stronghold on agriculture and economics. In the conversation with the BBC, he has listed many reasons besides the above arguments, due to which the government is not accepting the MSP related demands of the farmers.
Reason 3 - Private companies will not be ready to buy crop on MSP
According to RS Ghuman, if the governments buy less in the future, then obviously farmers will sell crops to private companies. If private companies buy on MSP, then they can be hurt (market prices are not always the same) and if they buy less then they will be sued. (If the government accepts the MSP condition of the farmers).
Therefore, the government does not want to impose this condition on private companies. There are some interests of the government also involved in this and private companies will also have problems with this.
Although holding the post of Agriculture Secretary in the Central Government, Siraj Hussain does not believe that the government does not want to do so due to the dominance of the corporate. They do not accept this argument.
Reason 4 - Farmers may also be in trouble
According to RS Ghuman, the government's hesitation on MSP in terms of the economy can also be understood in another way. For this, it is important to understand two words.
The first word is 'monopoly'. Meaning when the seller sells the same and his own arbitrary, then he charges an arbitrary price.
The second word is 'monopsony'. Meaning that the buyer is only one and he is arbitrary, that is, he will buy the goods at whatever price he wants.
RS Ghuman says that with the new laws passed by the government, 'monopsony' is going to be made in the agriculture sector in the coming days. If only a few companies make a cartel in the agricultural sector, then the farmers will have to sell the goods at the price they decide.
If the provision of MSP is added to the law, then the domination of private companies over farmers can end. The result can also be that these companies will buy fewer crops.
There is no way for the government to force private companies to buy the entire crop on MSP. That too when the government is already making up its mind to buy less crop of farmers.
In such a situation, the problem may also increase for the farmer. To whom will he sell his crop? In such a situation, the MSP may not even be able to remove their cost.
Reason 5: The basis of the price of the crop - the government wants to avoid deciding
Says RS Ghuman, "MSP - gives farmers a minimum basis for fixing the price of the crop, gives a reference point so that the price of the crop is not less than that. The MSP provides them a social security.
Whereas private companies decide the prices of goods according to demand and supply. This is their argument.
Therefore, the government does not want to get into a dispute on both sides.
The government wants to keep this whole issue bilateral. If the provision of MSP is added to the law, three parties will be involved in every lawsuit related to it - one government, one farmer, and a third private company.
What is the solution to the dispute?
It is estimated that 85 percent of small farmers in India have less than five acres of land for cultivation.
RS Ghuman believes that even after declaring the purchase below MSP a crime, the dispute does not seem to end. The only way out is to withdraw all three laws.
At present, the government does not seem to be ready to withdraw the law.
But former agriculture secretary Siraj Hussain says, one way of this is that the government should give direct financial support to the farmers as is being done through the farmer Samman Nidhi.
And the second solution is that farmers should grow other crops that are in demand in the market. At present, farmers put more emphasis on only wheat, paddy and farmers pay less attention to pulses and oilseed. With this, the dynamics of the market will remain.
Former England spinner wants to include Yuzvendra Chahal directly in India Test team, gave this statement
Indian team leg-spinner Yuzvendra Chahal plays only limited-overs cricket, but England legend Graeme Swann says that he would like to keep Chahal in the team without any question in Test cricket. The
India Vs South Africa 2nd Test: Team India standing on the threshold of making history in Johannesburg, rain can become a roadblock
The second match of the 3-match Test series will be played between India and South Africa from today. The match will take place at the Wanderers Stadium in Johannesburg. Team India has a golden
Lok Sabha Election 2024: What does the foreign media say about BJP's victory? The New York Times report will shock you
Indian media was already painted in the election color even before the bugle of the Lok Sabha elections 2024 was blown, media institutions and celebrities from all over the world not only showed
UP Police Constable Re Exam 2024: Letter fixing the date of constable recruitment exam goes viral, the board said - the letter is completely fake and misleading
No date has been decided yet for the constable recruitment examination in Uttar Pradesh Police, but a fake letter regarding it went viral on social media. On Friday, a letter from the UP Police
Diwali Bonus: Good news for central employees before Diwali, the government announced bonuses, these are the conditions
The PM Narendra Modi-led central government has approved bonuses ahead of Diwali for Group C and non-gazetted Group B rank officers, including paramilitary forces. The Finance Ministry has set a limit
Supreme Court: Supreme Court said- a mother has the right to include her child in the new family
The Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that a mother who remarries after the death of the biological father can decide the surname of the child and include him in her new family. A bench of Justice
UK virus reaches India: 6 patients infected with new strain found, corona spreads 70% faster
A new strain of coronavirus has also reached India. Here six viruses have been found in this virus. All of them had recently returned from Britain. Three of these samples were sent to institutes in
Indian defense sector gives the highest number of jobs in the world: Statista report claims, even surpasses US-China
The Defense Ministry of India is at the forefront of the world in terms of providing jobs or employment. This claim has been made by the German company Statista. Statista is a private organization
256 Indian students will return from Kharkiv, Ukraine today: Air India special flight leaves for Ukraine, will return to India at 10.15 pm
Because of the ongoing tension in Ukraine, four more flights will be operated. Issuing an advisory, the Embassy of India said that four flights from Kyiv to Delhi will be operated on February 25,
AIIMS Cyber Attack: Union Minister of State Rajeev Chandrasekhar told AIIMS cyber attack was a big conspiracy
Minister of State for Electronics and IT, Rajeev Chandrasekhar has described the AIIMS cyber attack case as a big conspiracy. He said that some big gang or any country could also be behind this
