First, read this comment…
'If a married woman is asked to do household chores for the family, she cannot be compared with a servant. If the woman does not want to do household chores, then she should tell this thing before marriage, so that the husband and wife can reconsider marriage.
On 21 October 2022, a two-judge bench in the Bombay High Court said these things in a case. With this remark, the case registered under section 482 of CrPC was dismissed. Bhaskar will know in the explainer what is the meaning of this high court's comment on married women?
First, know the whole matter
A complaint was lodged by a woman at Bhagyanagar police station in the Nanded district of Maharashtra. In this complaint, three big allegations were made against the husband and in-laws.
1. After a month of marriage, the husband and his family members started treating the woman like a servant.
2. The husband and in-laws demanded Rs 4 lakh from the woman's father to buy four-wheeled vehicles. Expressing his inability to pay that much money, he started harassing the woman.
3. One day for the birth of a son, the in-laws took him to the doctor. The doctor said that the pregnancy period is not complete. After this, the mother-in-law and sister-in-law beat her up.
FIR in 4 sections based on woman's complaint
After the complaint of the woman, a case was registered under 4 sections of the IPC at Bhagyanagar police station.
Section 498A of IPC: When husband or in-laws cause cruelty to wife. Provision of 3 years imprisonment with a financial fine if proven guilty.
Section 323 of IPC: When intentional hurt is caused under a conspiracy. Imprisonment for one year on conviction with a fine up to Rs 1,000.
Section 504 of IPC: Intentional insult. Imprisonment of up to 2 years and a fine of fine for the guilty.
Section 506 of IPC: Criminal intimidation. Imprisonment for 2 years and fine to the guilty.
The matter reached the Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court before Justice Vibha Kankanwadi and Justice Rajesh Patil. The husband and in-laws were defended by lawyer Sagar Bhingare.
The arguments of the in-law's side during the cross-examination…
Even before this, the woman has been married once. The woman had also filed several complaints against her ex-husband and his family members. The woman's ex-husband was either acquitted of all these charges or the woman herself withdrew the complaints.
Advocate Bhingare said that after going through all these cases, it is found that the woman has a habit of making such allegations. The woman was married on December 12, 2019, and filed the report on September 9, 2020. It is hard to believe that such an incident happened within 5-6 months of marriage.
The lawyer said that on 28 February 2020, only after 2 months of marriage, the woman's husband had bought a four-wheeler vehicle for 17 lakhs. At this time he had not demanded any amount from the wife's father. In such a situation, the question of demanding Rs 4 lakh to buy a new car again after 7 months of buying the car does not arise.
Thus, the husband's lawyer demanded that the case be dismissed. At the same time, the wife's lawyer said that the investigation has been completed and the evidence is before the court, so the case cannot be dismissed.
Bombay High Court's decision in this matter
The High Court dismissed the woman's allegations in this case. In the 10-page decision, the High Court gave these 6 important observations…
1. It is written in the copy of the case that a month after the marriage, the woman was treated like a maid, but this allegation is swift or vague.
2. The woman has allegedly made allegations of mental and physical harassment, but these 2 words alone are not sufficient to prove her guilty under section 498A of the IPC. Unless there is an unambiguous mention of acts of mental and physical harassment.
3. There is no mention of the woman being pregnant anywhere in the copy of the case, nor has there been any evidence related to being pregnant.
4. The court also said that there is no evidence that why the woman left her in-laws' house and went to her husband's house.
5. Why did the woman file a case after two months of being harassed by her husband, this is also not mentioned in the copy of the case.
6. If a married woman is asked to do household chores for the family, she cannot be compared with a servant. If the woman does not want to do household chores, then she should tell this thing before marriage, so that the husband and wife can think about marriage again.
When the matter of domestic women's work reached the Supreme Court in 2020
According to the OECD report, Indian women do 352 minutes of domestic work every day. Accordingly, they work 577% more than men. At the same time, men do domestic work for only 52 minutes a day. Indian women do 40% more domestic work than South Africa and China.
A case reached the Supreme Court in December 2020. A 33-year-old woman had died in the accident. The insurance company underestimated the value of her life by calling the deceased woman a homemaker.
After this, when the family members of the woman reached the Supreme Court, the court said, 'The importance of the work of women doing domestic work is in no way less than that of their husband'.
Apart from this, in another case, the Supreme Court had asked insurance companies to pay compensation of Rs 9,000 per month for the death of a woman between 34 and 59 years.
Aus vs Ned: Glenn Maxwell created a stir, scored a record-breaking century on Delhi ground, left Warner behind too
Glenn Maxwell Record AUS vs NED: Australian batsmen and bowlers created a stir against Netherlands in the 24th match of ICC ODI World Cup 2023. The Kangaroo team won this match by 309 runs.
RRR Award in Golden Globe: Natu-Natu song won the title of Best Original Song, music composer got emotional in the ceremony
SS Rajamouli's film RRR achieved the feat at the ongoing Golden Globe Awards in the US on Tuesday. The song Naatu Naatu from the film won the Best Original Song Award.
The price of Redmi Note 13 Pro+ with 200MP camera and 120W was revealed before launch, know the features here
Redmi has started preparations to launch the Redmi 13 series for its customers. Let us tell you that the company is preparing to launch this phone soon in India and on global labels.
Hearing in Atiq Ahmed and Ashraf murder case will be held in SC on April 24, murder happened in front of police in Prayagraj
Atiq Ahmed Case in Supreme Court: The Supreme Court will hear the murder case of Mafia Atiq Ahmed and his brother Ashraf on April 24. Along with this, the top court will also hear the demand for
Luna-25 Crashed On Moon: Russia missed out on creating history, these are five reasons for Luna-25 mission failure
Russia's 'Mission Moon' suffered a major setback on Sunday. Russia's Luna-25 Spacecraft Crashed before landing on the lunar surface. Launched on August 14, Luna-25 was to land on the South Pole of the
Reservation: History of Reservation in India; Such special arrangements in many countries including America-Canada
Reservation in India has been a very sensitive issue. There is a lot of politics on this. The reservation policy came after the independence of India. However, the idea had started coming before
Sunny Deol on Gadar 2: Sunny Deol proud of the success of 'Gadar 2', gave credit to daughter-in-law Drisha Acharya for this
Sunny Deol's film 'Gadar 2' has created panic at the box office. He has thanked people from the bottom of his heart for giving so much love to the character of 'Tara Singh'. 'Gadar 2' has achieved a
Canada: Khalistani terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar shot dead in Canada, NIA had declared him a fugitive
Canada Khalistani Terrorist Hardeep Singh Khalistani terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar living in Canada has been murdered in a gurudwara. He was shot at the Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara in the
MS Dhoni Retirement: Team India changed after the retirement of 'Mahi', second finisher not found; pair of broken 'kulcha'
Former India captain MS Dhoni (MS Dhoni) said goodbye to international cricket on 15 August 2020. On one hand, the whole country was immersed in the celebration of independence. At the same time,
Cyclone Biparjoy: How will Biparjoy, the increasing cyclonic storm in the Arabian Sea, affect the monsoon and the weather? Know
The cyclonic storm Biparjoy over the east-central and southeast Arabian Sea is moving northwards to intensify into a severe storm in a few hours. The Indian Meteorological Department says that another