The Supreme Court delivered its verdict on the Presidential Reference on Thursday. In the matter, President Draupadi Murmu had asked whether a constitutional court could set a time limit for the President and Governors to approve bills passed by state legislatures.
In fact, a Presidential Reference is established under Article 143 of the Indian Constitution. It is a special procedure under which the President has the right to seek advice from the Supreme Court on any legal or constitutional issue.
What is a Presidential Reference?
In simple terms, when the government has any doubts about a legal issue, a major public interest issue, or a dispute between the states and the central government, it resorts to a Presidential Reference. This simply means that the matter is referred to the Supreme Court, where it is considered, and the Court then submits its opinion to the President.
Since the government, under the Constitution, acts in the name of the President, the matter is first referred to the President. From here, the President, with his signature and seal, forwards the questions to the Supreme Court for consideration. This entire process is called a Presidential Reference.
What is Article 143?
Article 143 of the Indian Constitution states that the President has the power to seek the opinion of the Supreme Court on any question that is important to the country and involves law. This entire process is called a Presidential Reference.
At the same time, Article 143(2) of the Constitution empowers the President of India to refer certain disputes to the Supreme Court for consideration, which, as per the provisions of Article 131, do not fall within the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction.
The issue of Presidential References arises from the Tamil Nadu Governor Dispute
It is noteworthy that in April this year, the Supreme Court delivered an important decision in the case of the Tamil Nadu Government versus Governor R.N. Ravi. In its decision, the Court set a maximum period of three months for the President and Governors to approve bills passed by the House.
In this decision, a bench comprising Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Mahadevan stated that when a Governor sends a bill for Presidential assent, the President must take a decision within three months from that date.
The President expressed concern over the decision.
Subsequently, the President expressed concern over the Supreme Court's decision, terming it a violation of constitutional limits, and sought the Supreme Court's advice on 14 questions, including whether Governors and the President can exercise their discretion to indefinitely withhold bills.
What are the President's 14 questions?
According to a TOI report, President Draupadi Murmu has asked the Supreme Court 14 questions using a Presidential Reference.
When a bill comes to the Governor for his assent under Article 200 of the Constitution, what constitutional options does he have?
Is the Governor required to seek the advice of the Council of Ministers?
Can decisions taken by the Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution be subject to judicial review?
Does Article 361 of the Constitution completely bar the Court from examining the Governor's decisions under Article 200?
If the Constitution does not specify the time and manner for the Governor to take decisions, can the Court, through its orders, determine the time limit and manner?
Can decisions taken by the President under Article 201 (which relate to bills sent by the Governor to the President) be judicially reviewed?
Can the Court, through its orders, determine the time limit and manner for the President to take decisions under Article 201?
When a bill is sent by the Governor to the President for assent, does the President have to seek the advice of the Supreme Court before taking a decision on it?
Can decisions taken by the Governor and the President under Articles 200 and 201 be reviewed when the bill has not yet become law? Can the court consider the content of a bill before it becomes law?
Under Article 142 of the Constitution, can the Supreme Court, by its order, usurp the constitutional powers of the President or Governor?
Can a bill passed by a state assembly be considered law without the Governor's assent?
Is it not mandatory for a Supreme Court bench to examine whether a matter involves a substantial question of constitutional interpretation and refer it to a bench of at least five judges, as provided in Article 145(3) of the Constitution?
Is Article 142 limited to procedural matters only, or can the Supreme Court also pass orders that are contrary to existing provisions of the Constitution (both content and procedure)?
Can the Supreme Court resolve disputes between the Centre and states through an original suit under Article 131, except through an original suit?
Saudi Arabia: Bus-tanker collision More than 40 Indians feared dead on Umrah pilgrimage; PM expresses grief
More than 40 Indians are feared dead in a horrific road accident in Saudi Arabia. The accident occurred when a bus carrying Umrah pilgrims collided with an oil tanker. According to Saudi media
Salman Khan's craze is evident among children, as Bhaijaan is seen sweating it out, preparing for the Dabangg tour; watch the viral video.
Salman Khan has taken a break from hosting "Bigg Boss 19" and embarked on the Dabangg Tour. Rohit Shetty is now hosting the show in his place. Several videos from the Dabangg Tour are going viral on
Sheikh Hasina gets a death sentence. What did the court say while giving the verdict on the former PM of Bangladesh?
The court has delivered its verdict on five serious charges against former Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. The court found her guilty and sentenced her to death. This decision has caused a
Delhi's air becomes a 'medical emergency', AIIMS experts issue strict alert on rising air pollution in the capital.
Describing the capital's rising air pollution as a medical emergency, experts from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) said the crisis has become so widespread that government measures
Temperatures dip below 10°C in 16 districts of Rajasthan, snowfall continues in the mountains; cold wave intensifies in Delhi-NCR
The cold wave is now intensifying in North India. Since Tuesday, a cold wave has intensified across North India, including Delhi-NCR, Rajasthan, Punjab, and Haryana. The Meteorological Department has
Delhi Blast: Dr. Omar, who had shaken Delhi, had his house in Pulwama, which was razed to the ground; villagers revealed shocking secrets.
The house of Dr. Umar Un Nabi, the terrorist who carried out the Red Fort blast, has been demolished in Pulwama, Jammu and Kashmir. Villagers said that Umar was a quiet man, leaving home only when
Shashi Tharoor praised PM Modi's speech, Congress said - nothing worthy of praise.
Congress leader Shashi Tharoor's tone is constantly changing. Despite being a member of the Congress party, he is often seen praising various government decisions, including those of PM Modi, on
Delhi bombing accused Umar Nabi made a video before the attack, saying, 'Suicide is forbidden in Islam... but bombing is justified.'
Another video has surfaced of terrorist Umar Nabi, the main accused in the 2025 Delhi Blasts. Before the blast, Umar is seen discussing suicide attacks.
IND vs PAK: After the match, Indian and Pakistani players shook hands and applauded each other.
Blind women cricketers from India and Pakistan surprised everyone by shaking hands with each other in Sri Lanka on Sunday, putting the political tensions between the two countries behind them.
New revelation in Delhi blast: Brainwashed in a rented room... Jasir, at the last moment, denies carrying out a suicide attack.
Another shocking information has emerged regarding the white-collar doctor terrorist module. The mastermind, Dr Umar Nabi, had been searching for a suicide bomber since last year. Investigating
