New Delhi, Jan 13 (IANS) The Supreme Court Tuesday embarked on examining the desirability of having a separate cadre within police for investigating heinous crimes as it saw conflicting views on the issue within those advocating policing reforms and its insulation from political interference.
As amicus curiae Harish Salve advocated an exclusive cadre for investigating heinous crimes and former Uttar Pradesh police chief Prakash Singh sharply differed on the issue, the bench of Justice T.S.Thakur, Justice R.K. Agrawal and Justice Adarsh Kumar Goel sought the views of the Bureau of Police Research and Development chief.
The court asked Solicitor General Ranjit Kumar to ask the BPRD chief to address the issue of the desirability of setting up a separate dedicated cadre in police for investigating crimes like murder, dacoity, rape, economic offence and others involving sentence of ten years or more upon conviction.
The court will hear the BPRD chief during the next hearing Thursday.
The court order came in the course of the hearing of a challenge to Bihar Police Act, 2007 on the grounds that its provisions were not in conformity with the 2006 apex court directions on insulating police from political interference, separating law and order functions of police from that of investigation and setting up of an independent State Security Commission as a watchdog on police.
Advocating separate investigation cadre in police force upto a certain level which would then merge as it moves up in hierarchy, Salve said that the need for such a separate cadre does not spring from the need for specialised skilled investigators and insulate investigation from interference.
He said that law and order operations of the police have a distinct political component in the decision-making process.
Salve said in dispersing a huge gathering, as had happened in the case of Baba Ramdev's gathering in Delhi Ramlila Maidan in 2012, there is an element of political decision making. When to do it, how to do it, whether to declare assembly of people as an unlawful, whether to remove the crowd during the day or at night and its consequences are question on which the first call is taken at political level before police swing into action.
However, Salve was opposed by Prakash Singh on whose plea the apex court had in Sep 22, 2006 passed a series of direction for police reforms. He contended this would vertically split the police force and both wings would be perpetually at loggerheads with each other.
Opposing the vertical split, he told the court that the existing police system is good but has been made dysfunctional by vested interests by starving it of financial resources and adequate manpower.
At this, the court said: "What you are saying is that structurally there is no need to do any violence with the existing structure of police organisation but the men manning are responsible for the state of affairs. The question is how we can infuse life into it."
Earlier defending the provisions of the Bihar Police Act, 2007, the solicitor general told the court that it could not expect the legislature to enact the law on police reforms based on its recommendations.
Hooda government favoured Vadra in land deals: CAG
Chandigarh, March 25 (IANS) The CAG has blamed Haryana's previous Congress government led by then Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda for showing undue favours to Robert Vadra, the son-in-law of
Defending champions India down but not out (World Cup team profile)
Adelaide, Feb 13 (IANS) India are the defending champions. They are also one of the favourites. But a poor tour of Australia has shaken the belief of many that the World No.2 side will be able to
Theatre, art and puppetry: Alternative tools in education (Education Feature)
New Delhi, March 15 (IANS) Good education can build a strong foundation for a better future, but it doesn't guarantee the making of a better citizen. To bridge this yawning gap, schools, with the
Covid-19: Corona active patients cross 1.35 lakh, more than 16 thousand cases in last 24 hours, 41 deaths
The number of active corona patients in the country remains above one lakh, which is a matter of concern. According to the data released by the Ministry of Health on Monday (August 8), the number of
Uttarakhand tightens the dragon, now Chinese companies will not get any tender in the state
Companies from neighboring countries, including China, will no longer participate in the global tender for large projects in Uttarakhand. The government has imposed this prohibition by making changes
Weather Update Today: It will rain in these states including UP, Bihar, and Odisha today! IMD told the weather condition across the country
The weather pattern has changed rapidly in the last few hours in the country. Apart from Delhi-NCR, UP, and Uttarakhand, there has been raining along with strong winds in many states. After the rain,
Coronavirus Cases Today: 5921 cases of corona registered in the country in the last 24 hours, 289 people died
Coronavirus Cases Today in India: There has been a slight decline in the cases of the deadly Coronavirus epidemic in the country today. In the last 24 hours, 5 thousand 921 new cases of coronavirus
IND vs NZ ODI Series: Team India will now face New Zealand in the ODI series, know when and where to watch the match
India vs New Zealand: On the tour of New Zealand, the Indian team (Team India) won the three-match T20 series. Now he will try to win the ODI series here. The three-match ODI series between the two
Health Insurance: Payment of more than 150% of the premium received in Corona Insurance policies, now companies are reluctant to give Corona Armor policy
When Corona arrived last year, many insurance companies took it as an opportunity to earn and launched special Covid Mediclaim policies. But the estimates of the companies turned out to be wrong and
States should use additional funds for infrastructure: PM
New Delhi, March 4 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday suggested that additional funds and resources at the disposal of states should be directed primarily towards nation building, an
