New Delhi, Jan 13 (IANS) The Supreme Court Tuesday embarked on examining the desirability of having a separate cadre within police for investigating heinous crimes as it saw conflicting views on the issue within those advocating policing reforms and its insulation from political interference.
As amicus curiae Harish Salve advocated an exclusive cadre for investigating heinous crimes and former Uttar Pradesh police chief Prakash Singh sharply differed on the issue, the bench of Justice T.S.Thakur, Justice R.K. Agrawal and Justice Adarsh Kumar Goel sought the views of the Bureau of Police Research and Development chief.
The court asked Solicitor General Ranjit Kumar to ask the BPRD chief to address the issue of the desirability of setting up a separate dedicated cadre in police for investigating crimes like murder, dacoity, rape, economic offence and others involving sentence of ten years or more upon conviction.
The court will hear the BPRD chief during the next hearing Thursday.
The court order came in the course of the hearing of a challenge to Bihar Police Act, 2007 on the grounds that its provisions were not in conformity with the 2006 apex court directions on insulating police from political interference, separating law and order functions of police from that of investigation and setting up of an independent State Security Commission as a watchdog on police.
Advocating separate investigation cadre in police force upto a certain level which would then merge as it moves up in hierarchy, Salve said that the need for such a separate cadre does not spring from the need for specialised skilled investigators and insulate investigation from interference.
He said that law and order operations of the police have a distinct political component in the decision-making process.
Salve said in dispersing a huge gathering, as had happened in the case of Baba Ramdev's gathering in Delhi Ramlila Maidan in 2012, there is an element of political decision making. When to do it, how to do it, whether to declare assembly of people as an unlawful, whether to remove the crowd during the day or at night and its consequences are question on which the first call is taken at political level before police swing into action.
However, Salve was opposed by Prakash Singh on whose plea the apex court had in Sep 22, 2006 passed a series of direction for police reforms. He contended this would vertically split the police force and both wings would be perpetually at loggerheads with each other.
Opposing the vertical split, he told the court that the existing police system is good but has been made dysfunctional by vested interests by starving it of financial resources and adequate manpower.
At this, the court said: "What you are saying is that structurally there is no need to do any violence with the existing structure of police organisation but the men manning are responsible for the state of affairs. The question is how we can infuse life into it."
Earlier defending the provisions of the Bihar Police Act, 2007, the solicitor general told the court that it could not expect the legislature to enact the law on police reforms based on its recommendations.
Corona virus: Trump introduced lockdown removal plan
US President Donald Trump has proposed a three-phase plan to start normal life in the country.
Kiran Bedi's Election aide joins back hours after quitting
New Delhi, Feb 2 (IANS) Hours after resigning from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the political aide of the party's chief ministerial candidate Kiran Bedi joined back, terming his previous
Aus vs Ned: Glenn Maxwell created a stir, scored a record-breaking century on Delhi ground, left Warner behind too
Glenn Maxwell Record AUS vs NED: Australian batsmen and bowlers created a stir against Netherlands in the 24th match of ICC ODI World Cup 2023. The Kangaroo team won this match by 309 runs.
Palestine: Who runs Palestine, what are the political parties here? Know his relationship with Hamas
After the attack on Israel, the Palestinian terrorist organization Hamas has become a topic of discussion across the world. It carried out a major attack by tricking even the Israeli intelligence
BPSC Exam: Amidst protests, the exam will be held again today under tight security, static and zonal magistrates will keep an eye
Amidst the strong demand for complete cancellation of the integrated 70th Combined Preliminary Competitive Examination conducted by Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC), re-examination will be held
Honesty or dishonesty: When Mitchell Marsh left the field without getting out against Lucknow, the fans said the villain of the match.
It is said that no matter what happens, the batsman must know whether the ball has taken the edge of his bat or not. But something happened in the Delhi Capitals vs Lucknow Super Giants match, in
Complete lockdown continues in 8 states of the country, restrictions removed in many states; Know- the condition of your state
The pace of corona infection has started slowing down across the country. Despite this, there is a complete lockdown in many states of the country, and a partial lockdown with relaxation in many
America: Relief for Indian students, court quashes changes in H-1B visa rules of Trump tenure
In a major ruling on Friday, a US federal court canceled changes made to the H-1B visa rules of the Trump tenure. This decision of the court will give great relief to the students of many countries
The new variant of Corona found in India is N-440K quite dangerous, it can spread 10 times more than the others.
The coronavirus spread in India spreads 10 times faster than the coronavirus spread in the world and it is much more dangerous than that. The Center for Cellular and Molecular Biology (CCMB) has
Rural flavour in Rajasthan's royal Sara Vilas (Travelogue)
Mandawa (Rajasthan), March 1 (IANS) Golden yellow mustard fields, long winding roads, shimmering stars and a gentle wind whistling in the ears - that was the first impression that Mandawa cast on
