The Supreme Court will consider whether states can give reservations by declaring any class as backward on their behalf, or Parliament has this right after the 102nd amendment of the constitution? While hearing the challenge to the Maratha reservation of Maharashtra, the Constitution Bench has admitted that the situation has changed after the 102nd Constitution Amendment.
Therefore, it is important to consider the validity and effect of this amendment as well. A bench of 5 judges sitting under the chairmanship of Justice Ashok Bhushan has said that the case will have an impact on all the states. Therefore, they are also being given notice. The detailed hearing will begin on March 15. It will also consider whether the decision to maintain the reservation limit up to 50 percent also needs to be rethought.
In 2018, the Maharashtra government gave Maratha class 16 percent reservation in government jobs and higher education. The basis behind this reservation was made for the report of the Maharashtra Backward Classes Commission headed by Justice NG Gaikwad. The Maratha reservation, given aside from the 27 percent reservation given to the OBC castes, violated the Supreme Court's decision in which the maximum limit of reservation was asked to be 50 percent only.
This reservation was challenged on 2 main grounds in the Bombay High Court. First, there is no proper basis behind it. It has been given only for political gain. Second, it violates the Supreme Court judgment of Indira Sawhney vs. Government of India given in 1992 to keep the total reservation up to 50 percent. In June 2019, the High Court ruled in favor of this reservation. The High Court accepted that reservation can be given to a class in exceptional circumstances. However, reservation was reduced to 13 percent in jobs and 12 percent in higher education.
The Supreme Court has put a stay on Maratha reservation for the time being. Today a 5-judge constitution bench sitting to hear the case heard Maharashtra lawyer Mukul Rohatgi, Kapil Sibal, besides Attorney General KK Venugopal and other senior lawyers. Most lawyers believed that the case was not limited to Maratha reservation only. During the hearing, the validity of the 102nd Amendment and Article 324A of the Constitution will have to be considered. After this article was added to the constitution in 2018, the process of change in the list of OBC castes has also become similar to that of the Scheduled Castes. It has been written that with the approval of Parliament, the President can change this list. It is against the right of the Legislative Assembly to create a separate list for the state.
The court issued a notice to the states, agreeing with the plea that the impact of the case fall on all the states. The court has said that these things will be considered in the detailed hearing commencing from 15 March: -
* Was there such an extraordinary situation in Maharashtra that Maratha class should be given separate reservations, beyond the prescribed limit of reservation?
* Does the 102nd Amendment of the Constitution and Article 324A violate the authority of the State Legislative Assembly? Is this amendment and paragraph valid?
* Does the Indira Sawhney judgment of 1992 need a rethink? Should the decision of the Bench of 9 judges holding 50 percent of the total reservation be sent to a larger bench for reconsideration?
Government's tough stance after Rashmika Mandanna's deep fake video case, content will have to be removed within 24 hours of the complaint
Government On Rashmika Mandanna Deepfake Controversy: Rashmika Mandanna recently came into the limelight for her Deepfake video. The actress had informed through social media that one of her videos
Rafael FighterJet: Navy convinced of Rafale aircraft after Air Force, report sent to Defense Ministry, another deal may be done with France
INS Vikrant: Can India once again make a Rafale fighter jet deal with France? This question is because India needs 26 fighter jets for the indigenous aircraft carrier, INS Vikrant, and a special
Congress's foot march today on ED's notice: Congress leaders and officials will leave for Lucknow in the morning from Kanpur, and will oppose the Center
Congress President Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi have been summoned on Monday on the ED's notice in the National Herald case. Regarding this, Congress is going on a foot march in all the state
Corona in the country: 2.64 lakh infected were found in a day, 1.09 lakh were cured; Schools in MP closed till 31 January
In the last 24 hours, 2 lakh 64 thousand 202 corona infections were found in the country. 1 lakh 9 thousand 345 patients were cured and 315 died. For the first time in the third wave of Corona, most
Covid-19: Infection of new variants increased in many countries, will another booster vaccine be needed for protection?
There are reports of increasing cases of new variants of Corona in many countries of the world. In many other countries including UK-US and Singapore, the number of patients in hospitals has increased
Shane Warne Death: Team India came out wearing a black band, kept silence for two minutes, paid tribute to Shane Warne
Former Australian cricketer Shane Warne has passed away. Both the teams paid tribute to him before the start of the second day of the Test match against Sri Lanka. Two minutes of silence was observed
Petrol Diesel Price: Oil companies have released the prices of petrol and diesel, know how much are the prices in your city
Oil companies have released the prices of petrol and diesel for today. Today companies have not made any change in oil prices. Recently, the government announced to reduce the prices of petrol and
Relief: After Britain bowed down, India also gave relief to British travelers, now there will be no quarantine for 10 days
After Britain bowed down on the quarantine rules, now the Indian government has also withdrawn its revised guideline on Wednesday. These guidelines were issued on October 1, 2021, after Britain took a
There will also be a serious discussion on environmental reform in the G20 conference, the benefits of an eco-friendly lifestyle will be explained.
Degradation of land quality, loss of biodiversity, increasing pollution in the sea, overuse of resources, and reducing the absorption of toxic substances will be discussed at the G20 countries
Politics of Halal vs Malhar in Maharashtra: Now only the Khatik community will sell Jhatka meat, Malhar certification website launched
Politics of Halal and Jhatka meat has now started in Maharashtra. State Fisheries Minister Nitesh Rane has released a website to start Malhar certification for Jhatka meat, in which this meat will be
