New Delhi, Feb 24 (IANS) The Rajya Sabha Tuesday witnessed a ruckus over the land acquisition bill as opposition members demanded a discussion on the bill, leading to the suspension of the business of the house.
Heated arguments were witnessed between the ruling and opposition benches as the opposition alleged that the government was trying to bypass parliament while the government denied it.
"We have given a notice. The whole country is agitated against the ordinance, there are protests going on in Delhi," Samajwadi Party leader Naresh Agarwal said.
Deputy Chairman of Rajya Sabha P.J. Kurien urged the members to discuss the matter when the bill on the ordinance comes to the house. "Ordinance has to be replaced by bill. When the bill comes you can discuss."
Congress Deputy Leader in the Rajya Sabha Anand Sharma slammed the government for trying to bypass parliament through an ordinance.
"We have given a notice under rule 267. The matter is serious enough to require suspension of business. The law passed by both houses of parliament was changed against the farmers," he said.
"We can't accept that the government will govern through ordinances overriding legislative scrutiny of parliament."
Leader of the House and Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, however, said it was unfair to say the government was bypassing parliament.
"No law can bypass the house. My friend should remember 636 ordinances have come and 80 percent of them came when Anand Sharma's party was in government," Jaitley said.
"There were 70 ordinances passed by the government of first prime minister of India (Jawaharlal Nehru). When my communist friends had the United Front government, in 18 months 77 ordinances came... So saying that we bypassed parliament is not fair," the minister reminded the Rajya Sabha.
"In the last government, medical council ordinance was re-promulgated four times. representation of scheduled castes and scheduled tribes ordinance was re-promulgated three times," he said.
"This bill is listed in Lok Sabha today. Depending if it is passed, every argument can be raised when it comes to this house. But you cannot prevent Lok Sabha from discussing it," Jaitley added.
Congress leader Anand Sharma, however, argued that the ordinances brought by the UPA government were "people-friendly".
"We had to bring ordinances because your party did not allow the house to function," Sharma said alluding to the Bharatiya Janata Party.
"We had to bring ordinance on right to food bill... Which of your ordinances are people friendly?" he questioned.
As Kurien appeared ready to let the members speak on the issue, Jaitley maintained that the discussion should be held only when the land acquisition bill comes to the house.
"This bill is coming to the house or not is only anticipation. Leader of the house said it is in the other house, it maybe but the chair of this house does not know what is going to happen. Therefore, there is no harm in having this discussion," Kurien said.
"I am giving only time of zero hour," he added.
Members were then allowed to speak on the issue.
Bahujan Samaj Party chief Mayawati said: "Ours is an agricultural country. Had the bill been in favour of farmers there would not have been so much protest."
Samajwadi Party leader Ram Gopal Yadav said the opposition should have been taken into confidence.
"The social impact part of the bill has been totally obliterated from the bill," Yadav said.
Trinamool Congress leader Derek O'Brien said the ordinance brought by the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government made the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government "look like angels".
Communist Party of India leader D. Raja said the bill is against "the livelihood of poor".
Jaitley, saying that the government has taken the points "positively" said: "I will convey these points to the minister concerned in a positive manner. The government must have discussion with all concerned parties."
The deputy chairman then resumed the zero hour, stating that the government has reacted positively to the discussion.
Burning of cargo ship may cause acid rain in Sri Lanka: Official
Sri Lanka's top environmental body has warned that the emission of nitrogen dioxide from a Singapore-flag cargo vessel could cause mild acid rain. Let us tell you that the cargo ship caught fire near
Provident Fund Starts Web Helpdesk For Inoperative Accounts
New Delhi, Feb 19 (IANS) The Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) has introduced an online helpdesk to help members trace out and settle "inoperative accounts", the labour ministry said
Salman Khan Gets Death Threat: Salman Khan has received death threats more than 12 times in 6 years, know who threatened him and when
Salman Khan, famous as the Dabangg hero in Bollywood, has been forced to live under heavy security for the last 2 years. The reason is that he is constantly receiving threats from the Lawrence Bishnoi
Typhoon Muifa: Port stalled in East China, schools also ordered to be closed; What is the reason after all?
Authorities in China's eastern province of Zhejiang have ordered ships to return to port. It has also asked schools to close and tourists to be evacuated from nearby islands as one of the most
Ankita Murder Case: People's anger was visible during the verdict, barricades were broken, and police dispersed them by spraying water
Given the verdict in the Ankita Bhandari murder case in Rishikesh, Uttarakhand, the district police and administration had made strong security arrangements by barricading every road around the court.
Israel-Hamas: Israel was not behind the attack on Gaza hospital, France said - this attack was caused by a Palestinian rocket
A fierce war has been going on between Israel and Hamas for the past several days. During this period, many people have died in both the countries. Many people also died due to the attack on the
Nawab Malik: 'Who is Fletcher Patel, what is the relationship with Sameer Wankhede?' Nawab Malik again raised questions on NCB
Mumbai
Russia Ukraine War: UN Secretary-General expressed displeasure over the massacre of civilians in Ukraine, demanded an independent investigation
The situation in the ongoing war between Russia-Ukraine is deteriorating continuously. The brutality of the Russian military has come under fire after 410 civilian bodies were found in Buka and some
'The country that nurtured bin Laden has no right to preach', Jaishankar lashed out at Pakistan in the UN.
India has given a befitting reply to Pakistan raising the issue of Kashmir in the United Nations (UN). India said that the country had hosted terrorist Osama bin Laden and attacked the parliament of
Karnataka IAS officer's family suspects foul play
Bengaluru, March 18 (IANS) The family of deceased IAS officer D.K. Ravi on Wednesday refuted the statement made by Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah that the bureaucrat committed suicide due to
