New Delhi, March 26 (IANS) The Supreme Court on Thursday hauled up Karnataka for not taking any position on the appointment of a prosecutor to appear before the high court in the hearing of the appeal by former Tamil Nadu chief minister Jayalalithaa, who has challenged her conviction and sentencing in a disproportionate assets case.
Taking exception to the Karnataka government invoking the shield of "neutrality" over the appointment, the bench of Justice Madan B. Lokur and Justice R. Banumathi wondered what if the "matter goes ex-parte before the high court".
As Karnataka government counsel pleaded that "when we are not a party before the trial court, we are not a party before the high court", the apex court said: "In sum and substance, your advocate general says nothing before the high court, you are also taking the same position."
The court's drubbing of the position taken by Karnataka came during the hearing of a petition of DMK leader K. Anbazhagan, who contested the appointment of G. Bhavani Singh as prosecutor by the Tamil Nadu government. Anbazhagan said Tamil Nadu government has no jurisdiction to do so.
He said the authority to appoint a prosecutor was vested in the Karnataka government after the trial was transferred from Tamil Nadu.
The court was told that Karnataka's advocate general did object to the appointment of Bhavani Singh by Tamil Nadu, but the high court disposed of the plea at the preliminary stage.
Karnataka said the appointment of Bhavani Sinbgh as special public prosecutor came to an end with the conclusion of Jayalalithaa's trial in the assets case.
The apex court asked that apart from the advocate general telling the high court that Bhavani Singh could not appear as prosecutor, "did you take steps to prevent him from appearing before the high court? (It) is one thing to say in words, (but) quite another (to do) in deeds".
Describing as "absolutely bizarre" Tamil Nadu appointing Bhavani Singh as prosecutor before the Karnataka High Court, counsel T.R. Andhyarujina, appearing for petitioner Anbazhagan, told the court that once the case is transferred to another state, it comes under the jurisdiction of the transferee state to appoint a prosecutor.
Contesting the appointment of Bhavani Singh on the question of law and facts, Andhyarujina said his conduct was adversely commented upon by the trial court judge.
Opposing the plea by Andhyarujina, counsel Fali Nariman told the court that Tamil Nadu appointed Bhavani Singh as prosecutor only after Karnataka did not appoint one.
Nariman will continue with his arguments on April 1 when the matter comes up for further hearing.
The high court on March 11 reserved its verdict on Jayalalithaa and others on an appeal challenging the Bengaluru court's September 27, 2014, order convicting Jayalalithaa of possessing assets disproportionate to her known sources of income and sentencing her to four jail terms and Rs.100 crore fine.
The case against Jayalalithaa and three others relates to the period from 1991 to 1996 involving Rs.66.65 crore when she became chief minister of Tamil Nadu for the first time.
Crude Oil Price Hike: The price of crude oil once again crosses $ 120, will the price of petrol and diesel increase?
Crude oil prices rose sharply after the start of the war between Russia and Ukraine. Even its price had reached the peak of $ 139 per barrel. However, after that it softened, but once the prices of
Know what is the treatment of Covid-19 cytokine therapy? Trial is going on in Karnataka
Doctors all over the world are using different medicines and therapies in the treatment of coronavirus, which is spreading waste. Some time ago in India, the clinical trial of Plasma Therapy was
Monty Panesar jumps into the 'Mankading' controversy, shares a video of MS Dhoni, and tells how to avoid getting out
Controversies regarding Mankading in cricket have been going on for a long time. The International Cricket Council (ICC) recently changed its rules and brought Mankading out within the runout. When
Accused of death from Coveshield: After the death of the doctor's daughter, the father asked for compensation of Rs 1,000 crore, said - trust in the vaccine is not good
A surprising case has come to light from Maharashtra regarding the corona vaccine. Filing a petition in the Bombay High Court, the father of a medical professor has demanded a compensation of Rs 1,000
Ceasefire in Ukraine and way to return to the path of diplomacy must be found: PM Modi
The annual G20 summit began in Bali, Indonesia, in which many leaders from around the world are attending. Addressing the first day of the summit, PM Modi mentioned many global issues and called upon
BJP's MLA supports proposal against agricultural laws in Kerala Legislative Assembly, party bidding surprise
In Kerala, the BJP's only MLA in the Legislative Assembly of the proposal brought by the P. Vijayan government of the state against the new disputed agricultural laws of the Center under the
Tata-Bisleri Deal: Tata group will buy a stake in a company selling bottled water, this is the complete plan
Tata Group is now planning to buy a stake in Bisleri International, the largest brand selling bottled drinking water. According to media reports, Tata Group has proposed India's largest packaged water
Over 69 thousand patients grew in 24 hours, 59 thousand people were cured, 979 people died; 28.35 lakh cases so far in the country
The number of corona patients in the country has crossed 28 lakh. So far, the Corona report of 28 lakh 35 thousand 822 people have come positive. On Wednesday, a record 69 thousand 196 patients were
Delhi border seal, no pass no entry
In view of the increasing cases of corona in Haryana, the government has re-sealed the inter-state borders. Although the focus will be on the Delhi border. Not only this, a High Power Committee has
SBI: Big relief for SBI customers, bank waives SMS charges on mobile fund transfer
There is news of relief for the customers of the State Bank of India. The bank has waived SMS charges on mobile fund transfers. SBI has informed us that by using USSD services, customers can now
