The Supreme Court will hear on Thursday a batch of PILs challenging the validity of certain provisions of the Places of Worship Act, 1991, which prohibits filing a suit to reclaim a place of worship or to seek a change in its character from the form prevailing on August 15, 1947.
A special bench of CJI Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice Sanjay Kumar, and Justice KV Vishwanathan may hear the matter. Several petitions are pending in the apex court, including one filed by Ashwini Upadhyay, who has prayed that sections 2, 3, and 4 of the Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991 be struck down. The petitioner says that these three sections violate Articles 14,15, 21, 25,26, and 29 of the Indian Constitution. According to the petition, all these are against the basic spirit and preamble of our Constitution. One of the various reasons presented was the argument that these provisions take away the right of judicial remedy to reclaim the place of worship of an individual or religious group.
This law was brought by the PV Narasimha Rao government.
In 1991, the then Prime Minister PV Narasimha Rao's government brought the Places of Worship Act. According to this law, a place of worship of any religion that came into existence before 15 August 1947 cannot be converted into a place of worship of another religion. If someone tries to do so, he can be imprisoned for one to three years and fined. The Ayodhya case was in court at that time, so it was kept out of this law.
Section two of this law says that if any petition or other proceedings regarding the change in the character of any religious place existing on 15 August 1947 are pending in any court, tribunal, or other authority, then it will be closed. At the same time, Section 3 of the Act prohibits the conversion of a place of worship completely or partially into a place of worship of another religion. Even Section 3 of the Act prohibits the full or partial conversion of a place of worship of any religious sect into a place of worship of a different religious sect or a different section of the same religious sect.
Section 4 (1) says that the character of a place of worship on 15 August 1947 must be maintained as it was. At the same time, Section 4 (2) talks about stopping those cases, appeals, and legal proceedings that were pending on the date of implementation of the Places of Worship Act. Along with this, this section also prohibits the filing of any new case. Section 5 of this law says that the Places of Worship Act will not apply to the cases related to Ram Janmabhoomi.
Why was this law made?
The Ram Mandir movement was at its peak in the 1990s. Due to the growing influence of the Ram Mandir movement, many temple-mosque disputes started arising along with Ayodhya. To put an end to these disputes, the then Narasimha Rao government had brought this law.
At least two petitions challenging this law are pending in the court. One of these petitions is from Vishwa Bhadra Pujari Purohit Mahasangh of Lucknow and some other people of Sanatan Dharma. The second petition has been filed by BJP leader and lawyer Ashwini Upadhyay. Both petitions are pending in the Supreme Court.
The petitioners say that this law prohibits judicial review. Which is a basic feature of the Constitution. Along with this, this law also imposes an arbitrary irrational cutoff date which reduces the rights of the followers of Hindu, Jain, Buddhist, and Sikh religions.
Is this law being opposed for the first time?
When the Central Government brought this law in July 1991, even then the BJP had opposed it in the Parliament. At that time, Arun Jaitley in Rajya Sabha and Uma Bharti in Lok Sabha had demanded that the matter be sent to the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC).
After the Ayodhya verdict, once again claims are being made about 100 places of worship across the country, including Kashi and Mathura, to be temple land, but due to the 1991 law, the claimants cannot go to court. The Muslim side is saying that this law has been violated in Gyanvapi.
Akshay Kumar: Akshay Kumar made an emotional appeal to fans, know what the 'Khiladi' said about 'Kesari 2'
Akshay Kumar, R Madhavan, and Ananya Panday's much-awaited film 'Kesari Chapter 2: The Untold Story of Jallianwala Bagh' has hit theaters on 18 April. Before the release, a special screening was held
'Take concrete steps instead of making hollow claims', Rahul Gandhi spoke to Amit Shah; also took information from CM Omar Abdullah.
Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi said on Wednesday that he has spoken to Home Minister Amit Shah, Jammu, and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah, and state Congress President Tariq
Delhi Stampede: Vigilance increased after the stampede, security forces deployed in the entire station premises; Crowd of passengers thronging
A day after the stampede at New Delhi railway station that claimed 18 lives, tight security has been put in place at the New Delhi railway station. Companies of security forces have been deployed
Covid: First case of corona reported in Odisha after two and a half years, 15 infected in Gujarat; three cases in Haryana
Coronavirus has started spreading in the country once again. The number of coronavirus infected is increasing in different parts of the country. In Odisha, a new case of Covid-19 was reported after
IND vs ENG: 'When I meet Akash Deep, I will hug him', said Yuvraj Singh, giving this statement on Gill's captaincy
The third match of the five-match Test series between India and England will be played at Lord's from Thursday. The Indian team has started preparations for this match. Jasprit Bumrah will return in
'Jihad against India, arms, RDX...', PAK expert claims Yunus government is hatching a big conspiracy against India.
Amidst the tension with India, Bangladesh and Pakistan are getting closer. What is happening in Bangladesh right now has been condemned internationally. On one hand, the Mohammad Yunus government is
Now, the No Fuel Policy will be implemented in Delhi NCR from November 1; five districts, along with the capital, will also be included.
The government may have given relief to vehicles that have completed their age in Delhi, but this relief is temporary. Soon, the government will be preparing to implement the new policy. When will the
Waqf: Benefits of Waqf law enumerated, Sangh will clear misconceptions; Rashtriya Muslim Manch will organize seminars in the country
After giving the Waqf Bill a legal shape, the Sangh and the government have started preparing to take on the opposition in this matter. In this sequence, the Rashtriya Muslim Manch will clear the
RCB vs DC : Delhi and Bangalore teams will come out to maintain the momentum, eyes will be on Virat and Starc
The teams of Delhi and Bangalore, which are in great form, will clash on Thursday. The 24th match of IPL 2025 will be played at Chinnaswamy Stadium in Bangalore. During this, Virat Kohli will face
Dhami government's action against illegal madrasas continues in Uttarakhand, three madrasas sealed in Kaladhungi.
Action is being taken against illegal madrasas and encroachment in the state. On Monday, the administration sealed three illegal madrasas operating in the city, which has created a stir among the
