New Delhi, March 11 (IANS) The government on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that the challenge to the validity of the constitutional amendment and the law replacing the collegium system by NJAC was "pre-mature" as the two statutes are yet to be notified.
"If challenge is pre-mature then the question of their interim stay does not arise leave aside the other contentions of their constitutionality and other aspects," Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi told the apex court bench of Justice Anil R. Dave, Justice J. Chelameswar and Justice Madan B. Lokur.
The government red flagged the challenge to the validity of the constitutional amendment and the NJAC Act, 2014 as the court on Wednesday issued notice on the Centre's plea seeking the transfer of cases before the high courts where similar challenges have been raised.
While staying further proceedings before the high courts, the apex court also said that since it was seized of the matter no high court would entertain any challenge to the constitutional amendment and the NJAC Act, 2014.
The court is hearing a batch of petitions challenging the validity of the Constitution (Ninety Ninth Amendment) Act, 2014, that provides for setting up the National Judicial Appointment Commission (NJAC) and for enabling statute, the National Judicial Appointment Commission Act, 2014.
While Supreme Court Advocate-on-Record Association, NGO Change India and Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL) and others are opposing the appointment of judges to the higher judiciary through the NJAC route, the Supreme court Bar Association has come out in favour of replacing the collegium system by NJAC.
Describing as "unfounded" the contention that parliament had no competence, power, authority or jurisdiction to pass the NJAC Act, 2014 in the absence of protecting provisions in the constitution, Rohatgi told the court that a law remains dormant unless it was notified.
Buttressing his argument opposing the interim stay of the constitutional amendment and the NJAC Act, 2014, Rohatgi said "the critical question is when it comes into force. It will remain dormant till it is notified. It is only on that date (notification) court could examine its validity."
"Crucial date is when it becomes operational. Till the time notification happens and some one's right has been affected," Rohatgi added, the court could not look into it.
The attorney general said that even the framers of the constitution favoured the middle course of the government consulting the CJI before appointing judges.
The government's resistance to challenges to the constitution amendment and the NJAC Act got an unexpected push when senior counsel T.R. Andhyarujina made a forceful plea for giving NJAC a chance asking "Whether the independence of judiciary is violated if the judges are not given power to appoint judges."
"Can there be a basic structure of the constitution where judges are given power to appoint judges," Andhyarujina asked, adding that nowhere in the world do judges appoint judges as was happening under the collegium system.
Andhyarujina cited the example of England, Australia and Canada where judges have no final say in their appointment.
Making a plea for giving NJAC a chance to function, Andhyarujina said that in England the 15-member Judicial Appointments Commission is headed by a layman with no judicial roots. He told the court that the first chairperson of the Judicial Appointment Commission in England was a woman - Baroness Usha Prashar.
Telling the court that the collegium system had run for 20 years, Andhyarujina said that "let the system (NJAC) work. Why we should condemn it" even before its gets operational?
Senior counsel and SCBA president Dushyant Dave supported the NJAC saying that the proceedings of the collegium system were shrouded in secrecy. He said that the appointment of judges was not a power but a constitutional function.
Saying the challenge to the twin legislations was stillborn, Dave wondered how the presence of the executive, judiciary and civil society violated the fundamental rights and the basic structure of the constitution.
The court adjourned the hearing till Tuesday (March 17) saying that some issues of constitutionality were involved and it would like to hear before taking a call whether it should be referred to a larger bench. The hearing will last for three days starting March 17.
JEE Main Result 2023: All India topper will be decided by age and application number in JEE Main result, know tie policy
This year there will be only one student on the All India Rank in the result because in case of a tie in the NTA score of two students, such criteria have been set that more than one student can't get
PM Modi reached Canada to participate in the G-7 summit, know why this visit is special
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has reached Canada to participate in the 51st G-7 Summit. The G-7 Summit has been organized in Kananaskis, Alberta. PM Modi, who has reached Calgary, Canada, will soon
Maharashtra: 9 killed in a horrific road accident on Mumbai-Goa highway, car badly damaged after colliding with a truck
A horrific road accident has been witnessed on the Mumbai-Goa highway in Maharashtra. Due to the collision of a car and a truck, 9 people in it died on the spot. Three women are also included in the
President of India: India stood by St. Vincent and the Grenadines even during the Corona pandemic: President Ram Nath Kovind
President Ram Nath Kovind, who is on a seven-day state visit to St. Vincent and the Grenadines, said on Wednesday that India always stands with the people of St. Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG).
Conflict politics intensified in Bengal: Center and Mamta government once again face to face; What will be Mamta's strategy on the transfer of the Chief Secretary?
The case of Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee not being included in the review meeting of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to assess the damage caused by Chakravarti storm Yas has been growing. The Prime
Delhi Air Pollution: There is no relief from pollution in Delhi-NCR, there is only smog all around; Know what is the AQI today
The country's capital Delhi remains a gas chamber. In such a situation, the people of Delhi are in trouble. There doesn't seem to be any relief before Diwali. According to the Central Pollution
AirIndia Express: Even today, more than 70 flights of Air India Express were canceled, 25 employees lost their jobs and the rest got an ultimatum.
Air India Express flight operations are being disrupted. This problem has arisen due to the crew members suddenly going on leave. More than 90 flights of the airline were canceled last
27th day of attack on Ukraine: Russian media claims - 10 thousand Russian soldiers have been killed in Ukraine war so far; News disappeared after pressure
Today is the 27th day of the Russia-Ukraine war. According to Komsomoliska Pravda, a supporter of the Putin government, 10,000 Russian soldiers have been killed so far in the war against Ukraine. The
Sunil Chhetri Retires: Sunil Chhetri announced his retirement, and will play his last international football match against Kuwait on June 6.
Indian footballer Sunil Chhetri will play his last international match against Kuwait on June 6. This is a FIFA World Cup qualifying match. On this day he will say goodbye to
Air India: Seven international flights of Air India cancelled, there is no fault in Boeing 787 fleet; DGCA revealed after investigation
The problems of Air India, which is facing its biggest crisis due to the Ahmedabad plane crash, are not reducing. Seven international flights had to be cancelled on Tuesday due to various reasons.
