Will Nehru-Gandhi dynasty reboot or fade out?


Posted on 19th Apr 2014 05:30 am by admin

Narendra Modi is not far off the mark when he says that the May 16 results will be the Congress's worst.

Drawing room and tea-stall chatter nowadays centres on whether the 128-year-old no longer a Grand Old Party will be able to reach the 100-seat mark in the 545-member Lok Sabha in which two MPs are nominated.

It must be mortifying for the Congress that this figure has become something of a psychological marker. There will be a faint sigh of relief in its portals if the party can cross it, and a precipitous plunge into despair if it cannot.

Yet, only three decades ago, when the party won 415 seats in 1984, few would have thought that such a low benchmark would become a crucial reference point for it.

The only consolation for the Congress will be that such wild swings of fortune are not unknown in Indian politics. After all, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which is on the verge of recording its best ever performance, won only two seats in 1984.

If anything, these fluctuations show that a stable two-party system is yet to emerge in the country, as in the West.

For the Congress, however, the focus has to be on the post-poll scenario since a defeat is staring it in the face. More than the future of the party, its members and supporters must be wondering about the fate of the dynasty. Will it gradually fade away or will be it be able to lift itself by the bootstraps to face the challenges which it never anticipated ?

Since four generations of the Nehru-Gandhi family - from Jawaharlal Nehru to Indira Gandhi, Rajiv and Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi - have been the mainstay of the Congress, it will not be easy for the party to cut its umbilical links all of a sudden.

The expectation is that not only will the party men feel like orphans in the dynasty's absence, unable to think and decide for themselves, but that there will be no one to keep them from indulging in fratricidal warfare - a role which only the family was capable of playing.

During the Congress's earlier periods of trouble, as the 1977 defeat in the aftermath of the Emergency, or the 1989 setback because of the Bofors howitzer scam, the party was fortunate in having charismatic family members like Indira and Rajiv to help it to claw back to power. If Rajiv hadn't been assassinated in 1991, it is quite possible that the Congress's 1991-96 stint would have been further prolonged.

At present, however, neither Sonia nor her son, Rahul, can claim the kind of charisma and popularity for which Indira and Rajiv were known. To make matters worse, their economic outlook is not in sync with the post-liberalization India, where individual initiative has greater salience in an atmosphere of capitalist enterprise in contrast to the family's earlier emphasis on a public sector-driven controlled economy.

Ironically, it is the Congress's arch-opponent, Modi, who has taken advantage of the prevailing mood of free enterprise although it is the Congress's prime minister, Narasimha Rao, who opened up the economy in 1991.

Is the fact of Rao not being a family member (though a loyal Congressman) a cause of annoyance to the family's feudal instincts, making it virtually disown the economic reforms which he started?

It is no secret that Sonia's disinterest in the reforms inhibited the Manmohan Singh government from energetically pushing them forward, thereby slowing down the growth rate in the last few years. The sluggishness could not but have pleased Aruna Roy, a member of the left-of-centre National Advisory Council (NAC) led by Sonia, who had been bemoaning the government's emphasis on growth.

Since charisma is much more than just being good-looking, the family will have to come to grips with the changes that have taken place since Sonia learnt her first lessons in realpolitik in Indira's household and Rahul came of age. The major change is that socialism has become "outdated", as Manmohan Singh said, probably in sorrow, because the doctrine has a fairly high number of followers in India.

They are present not only in the communist parties, but also in the academia and in the NAC. It is the "inputs" which this outfit gave to Sonia which derailed the reforms process. The Congress itself has a number of socialists in its ranks, including Defence Minister A.K. Antony and the Kerala unit, which refused to allow foreign investment in the retail sector in the state.

If the Congress is to have some chance of success in the election after the forthcoming one, which may be earlier than in 2019, it has to pay heed to Amartya Sen's call for a right-wing, market-oriented, secular party. For an avowed leftist like the Nobel laureate to take this line is probably an appeal to the Congress.

If the Congress pays no attention, the field will be left open for a right-wing, market-oriented party which cannot be called secular.

101 Like 23 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

India, China tensions: India is reducing military in Europe due to threat from China: US Secretary of State Pompeo

Everyone was keeping an eye on how India is seeing India-China tension, but the statements of US

Congress appoints new spokespersons, Media panellists

New Delhi, March 24 (IANS) The Congress, in an effort to expand its media outreach, on Tuesday

Kejriwal ready to change scheme after Center objects to doorstep delivery of ration, said - we don't need credit

Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Saturday said how the 'Mukhyamantri Gantri Ghar Ghar Ration Yoj

Assam: 'Mughals shaped India, I am proud of them', controversial statement of Congress MP Abdul Khaliq

Abdul Khaliq, Lok Sabha MP from Assam's Barpeta constituency, has made a big deal about the Mugha

US Capitol Riot: Trump Wanted To Change Election Result From Capitol Hills Riots? Congress committee made many claims in the hearing

Former US President Donald Trump seems to be implicated in the riots that took place on January 6

Paytm CEO assures: Firm will achieve EBITDA breakeven in six quarters, shares rise 4 percent

Paytm Founder and CEO Vijay Shekhar Sharma said in a letter addressed to shareholders on Wednesda

Happy Friendship Day 2023: The festival of friendship is being celebrated today, know what is the history and importance of Friendship Day

Friendship Day 2023: Friendship is the valuable wealth of a person's life. It is such a relations

Aruna Roy files PIL against Rajasthan panchayat ordinance

New Delhi, Jan 2 (IANS) The Supreme Court will Jan 5 hear

Scripps National Spelling Bee: Indian-American student creates history by pronouncing 21 words correctly

History was made last night when 14-year-old Indian American student Harini Logan won the title i

Champions Trophy 2025: Rohit Sharma and Ravindra Jadeja had a funny conversation while wearing India's new jersey, the video is making a splash

The excitement of the ICC Champions Trophy 2025 is being seen among cricket lovers. In the tourna

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash