SC Orders Rs. 4 Lakh in Damages to Rail Passenger's kin


Posted on 24th Jan 2015 05:10 pm by mohit kumar

New Delhi, Jan. Jan 23 (IANS) The Indian Railways will have to pay compensation to passengers for any untoward incident during their journey, including death due to cardiac arrest while running along the moving train leaving the platform.

The Supreme Court, dealing with a case, declined the Centre's plea challenging the Madras High Court award of compensation of Rs.4 lakh to the widow and children of Durai Somnathan, who had died of cardiac arrest while running along the moving train from which his wife and daughter could not get down.

The apex court bench of Chief Justice H.L. Dattu, Justice A.K.Sikri and Justice R.K.Agrawal Thursday declined the Centre's plea as Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi told the court whether running along a moving train could be considered as an "untoward incident".

The court said that compensation amount of Rs.4 lakh would attract six percent interest.

Finding that the court was not inclined to entertain the plea, Rohatgi told the court that the railways was ready to pay the compensation but urged the court to keep the question of law open.

Somnathan along with his wife and daughter March 4, 2008, had bought a joint ticket at Dindigul Junction for Kumbakonam town in Tamil Nadu's Thanjavur district. They boarded a train but just when it was about to move, they realised that they have boarded a wrong train, which was headed to Erode.

Somnathan deboarded the train but before his wife and daughter could get down, the train started moving. He ran along the moving train shouting for his wife and daughter. As he was running along the moving train, he developed chest pain and collapsed on the platform.

The Railway Claims Tribunal at Chennai while declining the plea for compensation held that though Durai Somnathan was a bonafide passenger, his case did not fall within the ambit of "untoward incident" under Section 123 (C) of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1966.

The railways while opposing the plea of widow Elambal and four children for compensation told the high court that Somnathan's death was not caused by "untoward incident".

However, the Madras High Court by its judgment of Sep 17, 2013, held that the death due to "cardiac arrest" came within the definition of the "untoward incident" as the same is not covered under exceptions to "untoward incident" under Section 124 of the Railways Act.

Having held so, the high court granted Elambal and her children the compensation of Rs.4 lakh along with an interest of six percent from the date of incident and nine percent from the date of its order.

0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Recorded in Bengaluru Test history: Pant becomes first Indian keeper to get Man of the Series in Test, Ashwin becomes the first bowler to take 100 wickets in WTC

India beat Sri Lanka by 238 runs in the second Test in Bangalore to clean sweep the two-match ser

Smartphone Launch Update: Realme Narzo 50 and Narzo 50 Pro smartphones may enter India soon, know details India equals China in infrastructure construction on LAC, BRO DG had a special conversation with ABP News

Realme Narzo 50 Series: Chinese smartphone company Realme can launch two smartphones under its Na

There were 64 lakh cases of infection in May

The National Population-Based Sero Survey has revealed that 0.73 percent of adults in India were

Australia power to 328/7 against India

Sydney, March 26 (IANS) Powered by a 182-run stand between Steven Smith (105) and Aaron Finch (

Kerala's Vizhinjam port project suffers setback

Thiruvananthapuram, Feb 20 (IANS) Kerala's dream Vizhinjam

Russia fires a hypersonic missile at Ukraine, what is the message to the world?

Russia's Defense Ministry has announced that the Russian military has fired a hypersonic ballisti

Russia Ukraine War: America will give one billion dollars of state-of-the-art weapons to Ukraine, so far 15 billion dollars of military aid

The US has announced $1.1 billion in new military aid to Ukraine. This aid will be of state-of-th

Fear of Corona: The havoc of infection in these 10 countries of the world, those who survived in three waves are also in the grip of devastation

There seems to be no end to the corona infection at the moment. With the arrival of the new varia

PM Modi Ghaziabad Road Show: Prime Minister Modi will establish BJP's color through road show today, CM Yogi will be with him

PM Modi is coming to address Western UP on Saturday. PM has a rally in Saharanpur in the first af

77-year-old donates organs at AIIMS

New Delhi, Feb 20 (IANS) A 77-year-old man became the oldest organ donor at the All India Insti

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash