Section 66A vague, nebulous, observes Supreme Court


Posted on 25th Mar 2015 12:32 pm by mohit kumar

New Delhi, March 24 (IANS) The Supreme Court, which on Tuesday struck down Section 66 A of the Information Technology Act, said expressions such as "grossly offensive" or "menacing" in it were vague and nebulous in meaning, and there were no manageable standards by which a person can be held to have committed an offence.

"Quite apart from this, as has been pointed out above, every expression used is nebulous in meaning. What may be offensive to one may not be offensive to another. What may cause annoyance or inconvenience to one may not cause annoyance or inconvenience to another," said a bench of Justice J. Chelameswar and Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman in their judgment.

The court said that use of word "persistently" for repeated sending of message is "completely imprecise", and wondered what would constitute "persistently" - sending a message three times or eight times before it could be described as persistent.

"There is no demarcating line conveyed by any of these expressions - and that is what renders the section unconstitutionally vague," the verdict said.

Not accepting the government's contention that expressions used in the section could be incapable of any precise definition but not constitutionally vulnerable due to this, the court noted the two opposing conclusions that could be reached in dealing with vague and nebulous expressions, citing two British judgments where on the same facts, judges arrived at opposite decisions.

"If judicially trained minds can come to diametrically opposite conclusions on the same set of facts, it is obvious that expressions such as 'grossly offensive' or 'menacing' are so vague that there is no manageable standard by which a person can be said to have committed an offence or not to have committed an offence," it held, terming the expressions used in Section 66A "completely open-ended and undefined".

None of the expressions used in Section 66A - not even "criminal intimidation" with the act's definition clause - not saying that the words and expressions defined in the Indian Penal Code will apply here.

Thus, "authorities who are to enforce Section 66A have absolutely no manageable standard by which to book a person for an offence under Section 66A".

"This being the case, having regard also to the two English precedents, it is clear that Section 66A is unconstitutionally vague," the verdict said.

0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Does Sharad Pawar himself now want to take over the reins of UPA? Congress also reacted to the signals

Due to the continuous defeat in the elections, questions have been raised on the leadership of th

SCO Interior Ministers Meet: India demands strict action against terrorism in SCO meeting

Minister of State for Home Nityanand Rai called for strong action against terrorism and drug traf

Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra: Rahul Gandhi's Nyay Yatra reached Varanasi, took blessings of Baba Vishwanath

Rahul Gandhi's Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra has reached Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh. Today is the second da

Jamia Millia Islamia Admission: Date to fill admission form in Jamia Millia Islamia extended

JMIU Admission 2020: Jamia Millia Islamia has extended the last date of online admission form to

Lockdown final option: Experts of the country agree with PM Modi's opinion; Where did the government lapse in the fight with Corona, now how to defend

The corona speed in the country is increasing at a record pace. More than 2 lakh 50 thousand case

Total lockdown not in 5 cities of UP: Supreme Court ban on a high court order, Yogi government will now impose weekend lockdown in the entire state

Lockdown will not be imposed in 5 cities of Uttar Pradesh including Lucknow. The Supreme Court ha

BJP organization took the feedback of Yogi government's work, know what happened in a closed room

On Tuesday, the political stir at the BJP party office in UP intensified. Before the assembly ele

Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah: After 'Daya Bhabhi', now this famous character is leaving the show, knowing the name will give you a big shock

Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah: Whenever it comes to TV's famous comedy shows, the audience like

India has the potential to become a world leader in footwear, and leather: Piyush Goyal

Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal said on Tuesday that India has the potential to

In the US, the FDA is ready to announce the use of Remedicivir drug results positive

Washington. In the US, there have been many positive results of anti-viral drug Remadecivir for t

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash