Can the Supreme Court decide the deadline of the bill? President Murmu asked these 14 questions to the court.


Posted on 15th May 2025 11:29 am by rohit kumar

President Draupadi Murmu has objected to the Supreme Court's decision of April 8. In this, a time limit was set for the governors and the President to take a decision on the bill passed by the assemblies. According to the IANS report, this decision of the Supreme Court continued for a long time.

 

Draupadi Murmu has asked about 14 questions to the Supreme Court in this matter. The Supreme Court ruled on April 8 that the Governor will have to make a decision on a bill within 3 months.

 

What was the Supreme Court's decision?

If the assembly passes the bill again, the governor will have to approve it within a month. According to IANS, if a bill is sent to the President, the President will have to take a decision within three months.

 

President Murmu has objected to this decision of the Supreme Court.

 

President Murmu's question to SC

 

When a bill is presented to the Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution of India, what are the constitutional options before him?

 

If the Constitution gives full power to decide on a Bill, why is the Supreme Court (SC) intervening in this matter?

 

The President said that Articles 200 and 201, which apply to Governors and the President, do not prescribe 'any time-limit or procedure' to be followed by them while considering whether to give assent to a Bill passed by the Assembly.

 

Is the Governor bound by the aid and advice given by the Council of Ministers while exercising all the remedies available to him on the presentation of a Bill under Article 200 of the Constitution of India?

 

Is the exercise of constitutional discretion by the Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution of India justified?

 

Does Article 361 of the Constitution of India impose a blanket bar on judicial review in respect of the actions of the Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution of India?

 

In the absence of constitutionally prescribed time limits and manner of exercise of powers by the Governor, can time limits be imposed and manner of exercise prescribed by judicial orders for exercise of all powers by the Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution of India?

 

Is the President required to seek the advice of the Supreme Court by way of reference under Article 143 of the Constitution of India and the opinion of the Supreme Court before the Governor reserves a Bill for the Presidential assent?

 

Are the decisions of the Governor and the President under Article 200 and Article 201 of the Constitution of India valid at the pre-enactment stage? Is it permissible for the courts to pass judicial judgment on the content of a Bill before it becomes law?

 

Can the exercise of constitutional powers and orders of the President/Governor be altered in any manner under Article 142 of the Constitution of India?

 

Is a law made by the State Legislature without the assent of the Governor an enacted law under Article 200 of the Constitution of India? Does the Constitution preclude any jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to resolve disputes between the Union Government and State Governments except by way of suit under Article 131 of the Constitution of India?

 

Given the provision of Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India, is it not necessary for any Bench of this Hon'ble Court to first decide whether the question involved in the proceedings before it is of such a nature as to involve substantial questions of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution and refer the same to a Bench of not less than five Judges?

 

Are the powers of the Supreme Court under Article 142 of the Constitution of India limited to matters of procedural law, or does Article 142 of the Constitution of India extend to issuing directions/passing orders which are contrary to or inconsistent with the existing substantive or procedural provisions of the Constitution or the applicable law?

1 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

India-Pak Tension: Pakistan retreated due to its strong air defense system, the S-400 missile system is the hero of Operation Sindoor

Amar Ujala had a special conversation with retired Army Air Defense Colonel Urvinder Singh about

Operation Sindoor: The Saudi Arabian minister suddenly reached Delhi amidst India-Pakistan tension, Iranian foreign minister also came

After Operation Sindoor, tensions between India and Pakistan are at their peak. Countries around

'If we are attacked, then...', S Jaishankar's big statement in front of Iran's Foreign Minister

Tension continues between India and Pakistan. India has attacked 9 terrorist bases of Pakistan. N

Operation Sindoor: The echo of 'Operation Sindoor' was heard a lot in China; India was successful in giving a strong message to the world.

There is both a story and silence behind every storm. Operation Sindoor is not over yet, but its

Virat Kohli: After retirement from Test cricket, Virat Kohli met Saint Premananda, wife Anushka was seen with him

Virat Kohli, who has retired from Test cricket, and his wife Anushka Sharma reached Vrindavan on

Waqf Act Row: Hearing on petitions against Waqf Amendment Act in Supreme Court today, many states have challenged it

The Supreme Court will hear petitions against the constitutional validity of the Waqf (Amendment)

BSF Constable Returns: Pakistan bows down to India, hands over BSF Jawan Purnam Kumar

BSF jawan Purnam Kumar Shaw, posted in Ferozepur sector of Punjab, had inadvertently crossed the

'How much hatred is there in their words?', Harshvardhan Rane's befitting reply to Mawra Hocane's statement

A heated debate has erupted between Bollywood actor Harshvardhan Rane and his Sanam Teri Kasam co

'No enemy of India can escape without punishment, ' Amit Shah said- the forces shook Pakistan with their power.

The BJP on Monday praised the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and said that in his add

India-Pak Tension: After Operation Sindoor, news of explosion-like sound in Lahore, Pakistan, on high alert

After the Indian Army's Operation Sindoor on Pakistani terrorist hideouts, there is news of a bla

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash