Don't ban 'India's Daughter': Panelists


Posted on 21st Mar 2015 12:41 pm by mohit kumar

New Delhi, March 20 (IANS) Increasing violence against women and stifling of debate were among the issues highlighted at a discussion relating to the controversial documentary "India's Daugther" with the panelists saying it should not be banned.

Senior journalist Pamela Phillipose opposed the ban on the documentary relating to the victim of the brutal gangrape in Delhi on December 16, 2012.

"It should not be banned, it is deepening the discourse," she said. "We are living in increasingly difficult times, increasing violence on women and stifling of debate is a major problem," Phillipose said.

The discussion on some of the issues that have emerged in the context "India's Daughter" was organised at Indian Women's Press Corps here.

Phillipose appreciated the film maker for getting the voices of the victim's parents but highlighted the absence of the voice of Nirbaya's male companion who was with her on the day.

"It is not an Indian story, it belongs to the world. Anything that happens in the public belongs to the world," said Phillipose.

However, she termed the "highly publicised launch of the documentary" as "disgraceful."

Dibang, a journalist who co-produced the documentary, said he had tried to get Nirbaya's companion for three-and-a-half months.

He said the person gave two appointments but didn't turn up.

"BBC doesn't allow money to be paid. One of the accused, Mukesh Singh, claimed that the male companion hid behind a seat during the crime," said Dibang.

Dibang said Nirbaya's parents thanked him and said that he was fighting their fight.

Indu Agnihotri, director of Centre for Women's Development Studies, said India was not doing enough with the vast crime data it has and asked the media to examine it.

"Crime at the bottom of the society is coming to limelight, crime of corporates is not coming (to the limelight). Government goes away scotfree," said Agnihotri.

She said "normalisation of violence" is happening in India and focus today has shifted to urban violence.

Agnihotri said: "Everybody is talking about smart cities when rural India is sinking where majority of women live."

Jagmati Sangwan, general secretary, All India Democratic Women's Association (AIDWA), said her organisation feels the ban on documentary was unnecessary.

"It is an assault on freedom of expression. In the past also, convicted criminals were interviewed."

Referring to British film maker Lelee Udwin coming to India and making the documentary, Sangwan said it was not a question of an "outsider" coming and making a film and international solidarity on such issues should be accepted.

The Delhi High Court, earlier this week, said the ban on the telecast of the controversial documentary will continue and asked the central government to place before it the advisory issued by it to prohibit exhibition of the documentary. The documentary had been telecast by the BBC in Britain.

The documentary is about the gangrape of a 23-year-old trainee physiotherapist, who was brutally assaulted on December 16, 2012 in a moving bus in Delhi.

The documentary kicked up a storm after one of the convicts Mukesh Singh was interviewed in Delhi's Tihar Jail.

The documentary also has comments from the convicts' counsels A.P. Singh and M.L. Sharma, who allegedly made derogatory remarks against women. The banning of the telecast of the documentary in all formats caused an uproar in India.

The central government on March 3 issued an advisory to ban the broadcast of the documentary.

0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Hamas Israel War: 'Israel ready to stop the war a little, but...', know what PM Netanyahu said on the ceasefire

The ongoing war between Israel and Hamas is going to last for about a month. The chances of this

Inauguration of Shivamogga Airport: PM Modi said - the day is not far when countrymen will travel in 'Make in India' aircraft

Prime Minister Narendra Modi reached Karnataka on Monday. He first inaugurated the Shivamogga Air

Corona Virus In India Update: 1,965 Figures Reached In The Country, 50 Deaths So Far

New Delhi

The number of corona patients in India is steadily increasing. Corona has sprea

IND vs IRE T20 Playing 11: Bumrah will have 'fitness test' in Ireland, eyes on Samson; Know Possible Playing-11

The first match of the three-match T0 series between India and Ireland will be played in Dublin o

EC press conference at 4.30 pm: Election dates will be announced in 5 states, BJP government in only one of these states

There will be a press conference on Friday at 4.30 pm from the Election Commission. In this, the

Google Slows Hiring: Now there is no 'job' even in Google, Sundar Pichai said - this year the company will slow down the restoration process

Alphabet's company Google will slow down its restoration process in the remaining months of this

America-India iCET Meet: US NSA meeting with PM Modi and Foreign Minister Jaishankar, India-America will remove all obstacles in the way

With the start of PM Narendra Modi's tenure for the third time, the work of taking forward the bi

Gujarat Election: Owaisi will benefit BJP on Muslim majority seats! The figures of the last elections will surprise

Muslims constitute 9.67 percent of the population in Gujarat. The share of Muslim voters is 15 pe

The Supreme Court asked the government - where will the poor get money to buy the corona vaccine? Where can we not adopt the private sector model?

The Supreme Court has asked the government about the price of the Corona vaccine, from where the

Nepal Plane Crash: Major plane accident in Nepal, Shaurya Airlines plane crashed in Kathmandu soon after takeoff; 5 people killed

Nepal Plane Crash: A major plane crash occurred in Nepal's capital Kathmandu on Wednesday. A Shau

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash