NJAC Act is still-born: Nariman tells SC


Posted on 20th Mar 2015 11:37 am by mohit kumar

New Delhi, March 19 (IANS) The Supreme Court was told on Thursday that the National Judicial Appointment Commission Act, 2014 was a still-born law.

Pointing out that the Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 making a constitutional provisions for NJAC became a reality on January 1, 2015 only after President Pranab Mukherjee gave assent on December 31, 2014, senior counsel Fali Nariman told the apex court bench of Justice Anil R. Dave, Justice J. Chelameswar and Justice Madan B. Lokur that the government can't make preparation for implementation of a law (NJAC Act, 2014) which can be passed only now.

Appearing for the Supreme Court Advocate on Record Association which had challenged both the constitution amendment and the NJAC Act, Nariman told the court that parliament can't pass a law which is contrary to the provisions of the constitution and all exercises for operationalising NJAC will fall.

Telling the court that passing a law without supporting constitutional provisions goes to the root of the matter, Nariman said that it does not require a hearing by a five-judges bench to decide the matter.

Agreeing that parliament is supreme, Nariman said: "Of course, parliament is supreme. But it was not made aware in the statement of object and reasons of the NJAC Act and constitutional amendment as to why government went back on former chief justice M.N. Venkatachaliah Commission's recommendation for a five-member National Judicial Commission with three judicial members.

"You may change the mode of appointment of judges if you uphold the independence of judiciary and preponderance of judicial members," Nariman said adding that the government can't wish away the judgment of nine judges.

Earlier, when senior counsel Dushyant Dave appearing for the Supreme Court Bar Association sought to stump Nariman by referring to his criticism of collegium system, Nariman retorted saying that "criticism does not entitle the Executive to assume power" for appointing judges.

Dave - also the president of SCBA - supported the NJAC saying that the court could not stay a constitutional amendment and it was only in rarest of rare situation that the operation of a statute was put on hold.

Senior counsel T.R. Andhyarijuna submitted: "We are plunging into an uncharted field. Both the constitution amendment and NJAC Act, 2014 are a law. It has to be brought into operation. Until it is brought into operation, only then it can be examined."

Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi in his intervention once again told the court that challenge to both - the constitutional amendment and NJAC Act - was pre-mature and academic as it has yet to be operationalised.

He said that even after NJAC Act is operationalised it can't be challenged next day as a cause for challenging its validity has to surface before it is challenged.

The court was told this in the course of the hearing a batch of petitions challenging validity of the Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014, that provides for setting up the National Judicial Appointment Commission (NJAC) and for enabling statute the National Judicial Appointment Commission Act, 2014.

The hearing will continue March 24.

Did you know?Explore Trending and Topic pages for more stories like this.
0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Roadmap for 2024 T20 World Cup begins: Hardik said – New talent will get a chance, the young player has the opportunity to prove in New Zealand

Team India will start the T20 series in Wellington on 18 November on a New Zealand tour. All-roun

Agriculture Act: BJP MP Varun Gandhi again supported farmers, shared a video of former PM

Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) MP from Pilibhit, Varun Gandhi has once again supported the farmer

Modi to attend Lee's funeral

New Delhi, March 24 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi will attend the funeral of former Singa

Purple cap in IPL 2022: Yuzvendra and Natarajan shared 12-12 wickets; Still, Chahal retains his purple cap, know why

Purple cap in IPL 2022: Sunrisers Hyderabad fast bowler T Natarajan took a wicket in the 28th mat

Who is Ashish, son of Union Minister of State for Home: Ashish Mishra, who has been booked for murder, handles the family business in Lakhimpur, is also preparing to contest elections.

A case of murder has been registered against Union Minister of State for Home Ajay Mishra's son A

Actor Govinda: Govinda stated after the accident, expressed gratitude to the doctors, also said thank you to the fans

Actor Govinda had an accident today on Tuesday morning. He was leaving for Kolkata in the morning

Corona Curfew in UP: Night Corona curfew ends in UP, now restrictions on the opening of shops are over

It has been announced to end the night corona curfew in Uttar Pradesh from Saturday. Due to this,

Rajasthan Politics: Congress has a big plan behind giving clean chit to Gehlot! Who will bow down to the 'magician' or the pilot?

The political crisis of Rajasthan is taking a new turn every day. After the rebellion of the Gehl

Biparjoy Updates: The effect of Cyclone Biparjoy is visible, alert was issued from Maharashtra to Gujarat; many trains canceled

Cyclone Biparjoy is still two days away from making landfall in India, but its effects have alrea

Train engulfed in flames running on track: accident in Mexico, fuel truck collided with a goods train

A horrific collision occurred between a freight train and a truck in Mexico. The train caught fir

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash