Penalty imposed for offence should be proportionate: SC


Posted on 23rd Mar 2015 11:14 am by mohit kumar

New Delhi, March 21 (IANS) The Supreme Court has said that it was incumbent upon courts to bear in mind the impact of the offence on the society including on the victim and there should be proportionality between the offence committed and the penalty imposed.

Holding that "sentencing for any offence has a social goal", a bench of Justice Dipak Misra and Justice Prafulla C. Pant in a recent judgment said: "It is obligatory on the part of the Court to keep in mind the impact of the offence on the society, and its ramification including the repercussion on the victim."

"For the purpose of just and proper punishment, not only the accused must be made to realize that the crime was committed by him, but there should be proportionality between the offence committed and the penalty imposed," said Justice Pant pronouncing the judgment.

"In each case, facts and circumstances of that case are always required to be taken into consideration," the court said, while upholding the November 8, 2011 verdict of Punjab and Haryana High Court confirming the conviction of Assistant Sub-Inspector Sanjiv Kumar by a court in Punjab's Kapurthala.

Posted in a police station in Phagwara city, he entered the premises of a foreign exchange dealer and took away Rs.6,64,576 in Indian currency and foreign currency of the value of Rs. 13,44,500.

Not only that, he used a part of this money to foist a case on the firm's proprietor Sukhraj Singh, showing it as having been recovered from his car after it was intercepted at a checkpoint outside the town.

However, on investigation, this case was found to be false.

Thereafter Sukhraj Singh lodged a complaint with deputy inspector general of police, internal vigilance cell, recording the manner in which robbery was committed from the premises of his firm.

Sanjiv Kumar was convicted by the Kapurthala sessions court for offences under section 395 (Punishment for dacoity), section 450 (House trespass in order to commit offence punishable with imprisonment for life) and section 342 (Punishment for wrongful confinement) of Indian Penal Code.

While the trial court upon conviction sentenced him to varied terms of imprisonment and fines, the high court reduced the sentence to three years with enhanced fine.

0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

IND vs SA: 'One of the 10 best innings in Indian Test history', Gavaskar praised KL Rahul's century

Lokesh Rahul's brilliant century in the first Test match against South Africa was praised by the

Trump played friendship with India! Indians living in America were allowed to stay for so many days

new Delhi. Due to Corona virus, the US government has allowed India's H-1B visa holders and green

IND vs PAK: Whether Pakistan will come to India to play World Cup or not, the new PCB chief reacted

Since October till now, the tussle between BCCI and PCB is not taking its name. After the stateme

Achievement: The government exceeded the monetization target of the last financial year, and succeeded in raising one lakh crore rupees

NITI Aayog Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Amitabh Kant while addressing an event on Tuesday said t

Uttarakhand: Piplisari village of martyr Harendra Singh, the body did not reach the village due to road closure

There is mourning in village Pipalsari of Gurtheta Gram Sabha of Rikhnikhal tehsil of Harendra Si

China's apps slipped down the ranks of popularity

China's applications, which were once very popular in the online segment among the Indian people,

Sri Lanka Crisis: World Bank came forward to help the financially troubled Sri Lanka, will give $ 700 million help

There is relief news for Sri Lanka, which is facing the biggest economic crisis in history. The W

Aryan Khan came out of jail on bail, but cannot do this work

Shah Rukh Khan's son Aryan Khan has been released from jail after three weeks in the Mumbai drug

Hardik Pandya-Natasa: Natasha's new post amid divorce rumours, is there a rift in her relationship with Hardik?

Indian cricketer Hardik Pandya and his wife Natasha Stankovic are in constant discussion these da

12 Pakistani arrested in Italy: wanted to enter Israel via Europe, suspected of plotting terrorist attacks

Pakistani fundamentalists are plotting to enter Israel through Europe. Italian intelligence agenc

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash