Penalty imposed for offence should be proportionate: SC


Posted on 23rd Mar 2015 11:14 am by mohit kumar

New Delhi, March 21 (IANS) The Supreme Court has said that it was incumbent upon courts to bear in mind the impact of the offence on the society including on the victim and there should be proportionality between the offence committed and the penalty imposed.

Holding that "sentencing for any offence has a social goal", a bench of Justice Dipak Misra and Justice Prafulla C. Pant in a recent judgment said: "It is obligatory on the part of the Court to keep in mind the impact of the offence on the society, and its ramification including the repercussion on the victim."

"For the purpose of just and proper punishment, not only the accused must be made to realize that the crime was committed by him, but there should be proportionality between the offence committed and the penalty imposed," said Justice Pant pronouncing the judgment.

"In each case, facts and circumstances of that case are always required to be taken into consideration," the court said, while upholding the November 8, 2011 verdict of Punjab and Haryana High Court confirming the conviction of Assistant Sub-Inspector Sanjiv Kumar by a court in Punjab's Kapurthala.

Posted in a police station in Phagwara city, he entered the premises of a foreign exchange dealer and took away Rs.6,64,576 in Indian currency and foreign currency of the value of Rs. 13,44,500.

Not only that, he used a part of this money to foist a case on the firm's proprietor Sukhraj Singh, showing it as having been recovered from his car after it was intercepted at a checkpoint outside the town.

However, on investigation, this case was found to be false.

Thereafter Sukhraj Singh lodged a complaint with deputy inspector general of police, internal vigilance cell, recording the manner in which robbery was committed from the premises of his firm.

Sanjiv Kumar was convicted by the Kapurthala sessions court for offences under section 395 (Punishment for dacoity), section 450 (House trespass in order to commit offence punishable with imprisonment for life) and section 342 (Punishment for wrongful confinement) of Indian Penal Code.

While the trial court upon conviction sentenced him to varied terms of imprisonment and fines, the high court reduced the sentence to three years with enhanced fine.

0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Inflation hit: Commercial gas cylinder became costlier by Rs 105, in Delhi the price crossed Rs 2 thousand

On the first day of the month i.e. on March 1, the price of 19 kg commercial LPG cylinder has inc

'If I was a selector, I would have picked Rishabh Pant in every team'; Former Australia opener supported the wicket-keeper batsman

Indian wicket-keeper batsman Rishabh Pant did not find a place in the playing XI of the first T20

IND vs SA: Steve Waugh's record on target of Virat Kohli, but will not be able to surpass Ricky Ponting and Graeme Smith in 2022

Virat Kohli has become the best captain of India in Test cricket. Now his eyes are to play his da

IND vs PAK: Whether Pakistan will come to India to play World Cup or not, the new PCB chief reacted

Since October till now, the tussle between BCCI and PCB is not taking its name. After the stateme

Nothing Phone 2 is coming, company released poster, will be equipped with flagship processor

Smartphone brand Nothing has confirmed the launch of its new phone Nothing Phone 2. The company h

Kangana Ranaut: Kangana got angry at those trolling Kamala Harris, and said- Americans are worse than Indians

Kangana Ranaut, who has made a special place in the hearts of people with her strong acting, has

Virat Kohli is again sad about MS Dhoni, while Raina is happy on getting the captaincy of Jadeja, see the reaction of other veterans

Before IPL 2022, Chennai Super Kings has given a big blow to its fans. Team veteran Mahendra Sing

Shock to Trump, who claimed the presidency in 2024: Daughter Ivanka said – will not campaign for father, has to give time to family

Former US President Donald Trump on Wednesday announced they to become the presidential candidate

Covid-19 in China: Zero Covid policy failed in China! public cost

On December 7, China suddenly relaxed its strict Zero Covid Policy without any plan. Since then t

America does not have a permanent ambassador in the country: Indo-American business may be affected, and conflict is possible on many issues

America's permanent ambassador to India has not been there for two years. This is the first time

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash