'How can the Chief Justice be involved in the selection of the CBI Director', the Vice President raised a big question.


Posted on 15th Feb 2025 12:45 pm by rohit kumar

Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar has made a big statement on the division of powers. He said that in a country like ours or any democracy, how can the Chief Justice be involved in the appointment of the CBI Director as per the statutory directive? The Vice President asked whether there could be any legal logic for this?

 

The time has come to reconsider

Jagdeep Dhankhar said that the statutory directives were made because the executive of that time had surrendered before the judicial decision. But now the time has come to reconsider it. He said that this does not match with democracy. He asked how the Chief Justice of India be involved in any executive appointment?

 

Decisions have importance

The Vice President said that the public presence of the judiciary should be mainly through decisions. The decisions speak for themselves. Decisions are important. He said that according to the Constitution if the decision comes from the Supreme Court, it has to be implemented.

 

Dhankhar said that any other way of expression other than the decision weakens the institutional dignity. He said that when we look at the world, we do not find judges considering all the issues in the way we see here.

 

The largest democracy will not tolerate it.

The Vice President said that executive rule by judicial order is a constitutional contradiction. The world's largest democracy cannot tolerate this. He said that when institutions forget their limits, democracy remembers its wounds. Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar said this at the National Judicial Academy in Bhopal.

 

Institutions should work within limits.

Dhankhar said that for jurisdictional respect and honor, it is necessary that institutions work within defined constitutional limits. Maintain a collaborative dialogue and keep national interest in mind. He said that Parliament has supremacy in law-making.

 

Judicial review is required so that the law is according to the Constitution. But when it comes to amending the Indian Constitution, the power lies only with the Parliament. No interference can be made in this under any pretext.

 

Interference is not according to democracy.

Any interference from any source from the legislature or the judiciary is against the Constitution. This is certainly not in keeping with democracy. He said accountability applies when an elected government plays executive roles. Governments are accountable to the legislature and, from time to time, to the voters. If executive governance is outsourced, accountability will not apply.

1 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

PM Modi: 'Now the EVs that will run in dozens of countries of the world will have 'Made in India' written on them', said PM Modi in Gujarat

On the second day of his Gujarat visit, Prime Minister Narendra Modi was honored in Ahmedabad. On

IND vs PAK: 'Shaking hands is just a tradition, not a rule', BCCI stands with the team on the handshake controversy; A befitting reply to Pakistan

The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) has finally issued a statement on the 'handshake

The challenge to the Waqf Act: 'There is a system of listing cases, we will hear the case accordingly', CJI told Sibal

The Waqf Amendment Bill has been challenged in the Supreme Court. However, it has been signed by

Tension on the border: Amritsar airport closed, schools closed today; people of border villages started migrating

There is tension on the India-Pakistan international border after India's Operation Sindoor on Pa

IPL 2025: Shreyas praised the bowlers for Punjab's victory, and Rajat held them responsible for RCB's defeat

Crediting the bowlers for the five-wicket win in the rain-affected 14-over match against Royal Ch

'Khiladi Bhaiya' is returning to create a sensation on the small screen; has Akshay Kumar landed a unique reality show on television?

Big screen superstars also rule the hearts of television audiences. While they may not be part of

Kunal Kamra Row: 'Kunal Kamra's life should be made into a comedy', BJP MLA gets angry at a stand-up comedian

Comedian Kunal Kamra, who is in trouble for making indirect comments on Maharashtra DCM Eknath Sh

'Water and blood cannot flow together', Indian delegations stressed unity against terror; Strong message to Pakistan.

Indian delegations abroad met leaders of several countries on Monday and reiterated India's resol

Bihar Election 2025: 'Jungle Raj' resonates in Bihar elections, Grand Alliance focuses on these issues.

Now, as we move toward the euphoria of the results, the Bihar elections have rarely seen such a d

Severe cold will prevail in Delhi, UP and Bihar, IMD has issued a rain alert in 5 states.

The month of November is almost over. Following snowfall in the hilly states, winter has begun to

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash