New Delhi, March 16 (IANS) The Central Bureau of Investigation Monday told the Supreme Court that the decisions on the fate of its investigations into coal scam cases were not influenced by the meetings that its then director Ranjit Sinha had with some of the accused.
Rejecting the contention that Sinha had overruled his subordinate officer on the fate of the investigations, CBI counsel Amarendra Saran told a bench of Justice Madan B. Lokur, Justice Kurian Joseph and Justice A.K.Sikri that in the majority of the cases, decisions were taken "virtually unanimously".
"In majority of the cases the decision was virtually unanimous. In any organisation there are bound to be differences. They (people working in CBI) are not rubber stamps. The strength of the CBI is that the cases are monitored at the highest level. If you file a charge sheet, it has worst repercussions for the citizen. We have to examine and evaluate what are the chances of success," he said.
His contention came as the agency sought dismissal with "heavy costs" of the application by the NGO Common Cause seeking a SIT probe into Sinha's meetings with the coal scam accused.
Sinha meanwhile told the court that there was nothing wrong in his meeting the accused as it was a part of the job of the supervisory officer.
While not admitting to the late night meetings with the accused, senior counsel Vikas Singh, appearing for Sinha, told the court: "It is a part of the job of the supervisory officer to meet and know the part of the story of the accused."
Describing the allegations that Sinha's meeting with the accused, some multiple times, resulted in favours to them as "absurd", Vikas Singh said: "No one will meet accused 140 times. I agree meeting them but not in a manner as alleged by Prashant Bhushan. If you have to favour something then you don't meet people 90 times. These things can be done on phones. These allegations are absurd."
Contending that the courts were not a "place to settle personal scores" and Sinha was being "hounded" after he demitted the office", Saran took the court through the noting of the CBI files relating to coal scam cases to demonstrate that Sinha had done nothing which can be traced to his meetings with the alleged accused in the coal scam.
Giving the specific instance of the coal mines allocated to the company associated with Vijay Darda - owner of a newspaper group and a former MP - Saran told the court that the official who investigated the case recommended filing of charge sheet in three cases with further investigation into the role of public servants.
He told the court that right from the joint director to the additional director to the then CBI director Sinha, there was one opinion that a charge sheet should be filed in one case and not the other two with further investigation into the role of public servants, if any.
He urged the court that Common Cause be slapped with "very heavy costs" as its allegations are "going to hurt the organisation, lower its image and effect its credibility."
Reeling out figures, Saran told the court that in as many as 29 cases there was difference of opinion between the superintendent of police and the deputy inspector general of police, in 27 cases, between a DIG and the joint director, four between joint director and additional director and in one case between the additional director and director.
The court was told that in the CBI, at every level in the vetting of the file by the next higher officer, the opinion of the officer is backed by recorded reasons either way.
Congress leader Digvijay Singh's brother and former MLA Laxman Singh has jumped into the controve
Delhi Police has arrested a YouTuber who honey-trapped a businessman and looted Rs 80 lakh from h
More than 100 world leaders are about to discuss a formidable problem that scientists call Earth'
Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya is going to hold a big meeting with the states on the scr
The Haryana government has got a big relief. The Supreme Court has quashed the order of the Punja
Airtel 5G Plus launched in this hill town, and JIO has launched in so many cities so far
5G Service in India: Airtel has started its 5G service in a hill city in India. Now people in ano
Cyclone Biparjoy, which arose from the south-central Arabian Sea on June 6, is moving towards Raj
The Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) has said that the bodies of Covid-19 victims who died at hom
GST Revenue: GST revenue increased by 15 percent in December 2022, Finance Ministry gave information
GST revenue in the country has increased by 15 percent to more than Rs 1.49 lakh crore in Decembe
The meeting of foreign ministers of G20 countries has started in Delhi. Representatives of 20 maj
