Supreme Court bluntly on 'Rewari culture', only SC will decide free gift


Posted on 18th Aug 2022 06:05 pm by rohit kumar

The discussion about Revdi culture has been in full swing in the country for a long time. In this episode, the Supreme Court said on Wednesday that the Supreme Court will decide what is the definition of a gift. Chief Justice Justice NV Ramana asked all the parties to submit their suggestions to the court by Saturday. The matter will be heard on Monday. The Supreme Court, while considering a petition seeking not to allow promises of gifts to political parties, observed that the issues raised in the matter are becoming increasingly complex.

 

The Supreme Court said that we will decide what is the gift of freebies. During the hearing, the court asked whether universal health care, access to drinking water, and access to education can be considered gifts. We need to define what a gift is. Can we call the promise of free fertilizers to farmers and free education to children gifts? It remains to be seen what is the right way to spend public money.

 

However, the Supreme Court has also said that we cannot stop political parties from making promises. The question is, what are true promises, can we describe the promise of free education as a gift? Can free drinking water, minimum required units of power, etc. be described as freebies? Can consumers describe the product and free electronics as wellness?

 

The court said that the concern today is the right way to spend public money. Some people say money is wasted, some people say it is welfare work. The issues are becoming increasingly complex. You give your opinion, finally, we will decide after debate and discussion.

 

The Supreme Court is considering the petition filed by BJP leader Ashwini Upadhyay. Political parties like Aam Aadmi Party, Congress, and DMK have sought intervention in the matter.

 

Aam Aadmi Party: Election promises not under review

 

The Aam Aadmi Party has demanded that election speeches and promises should be kept out of the purview of review. The party has said that the promises, claims, and speeches made before the elections come under freedom of speech. How can they be stopped? The party has said that the composition of the expert committee to be formed in this matter is not proper.

 

Congress: Concessions necessary for the constitutional obligation

 

Madhya Pradesh Congress leader Jaya Thakur said in the petition that the ruling parties were bound to provide the subsidy. The petition said that schemes for the upliftment of weaker sections cannot be called gifts. Thakur has opposed Upadhyay's plea and sought to be made a party to the case.

 

It has been said in the petition that it is the duty of the ruling parties running the government to uplift the weaker sections of the society and make schemes. Provide subsidy for this. The petition said that the subsidies and concessions given to the citizens are constitutional obligations and necessary for democracy.

 

DMK: Many aspects to be considered

 

The ruling DMK government of Tamil Nadu has said in the matter of freebies that its scope is wide. Many aspects need to be considered. It states that this practice can bring economic ruin to a state. Chief Minister MK Stalin's DMK, in its petition, argued that only a welfare scheme done by the state government cannot be classified as a gift.

 

It has been said in the petition, that the ruling government at the Center is giving tax exemption to foreign companies, and debt waiver of influential industrialists is being done. He said that the petitioner was trying to convert India from a socialist country to a capitalist country and the PIL would defeat the objectives of the Directive Principles of State Policy. On this the court said that you have presented your side, now let the court decide.

 

Central Government: Fear of economic disaster due to gifts

 

On behalf of the Central Government, SG Tushar Mehta said that our understanding of social welfare is to distribute everything for free, so I am sorry that this understanding is immature. He said that there should be a limit to giving freebies. Freebies affect the decision-making ability of voters and can lead to economic disaster.

 

Also Read: Crops Production: Wheat production may decrease on record production of cereals, pulses and oilseeds will increase

1 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

RG Kar Case: 'Police offered bribe with daughter's dead body'; Serious Allegation by doctor's Family in Kolkata Case

The case of rape and murder of a female doctor in a Kolkata hospital is continuously growing. Alo

Bade Miyan Chote Miyan: Title track of Akshay-Tiger's BMCM released, can it spread the magic of Amitabh-Govinda?

Bade Miyan Chote Miyan Title Track Released: Akshay Kumar and Tiger Shroff's film 'Bade Miyan Cho

India-Pak Tension: After Operation Sindoor, news of explosion-like sound in Lahore, Pakistan, on high alert

After the Indian Army's Operation Sindoor on Pakistani terrorist hideouts, there is news of a bla

Roadmap for 2024 T20 World Cup begins: Hardik said – New talent will get a chance, the young player has the opportunity to prove in New Zealand

Team India will start the T20 series in Wellington on 18 November on a New Zealand tour. All-roun

Budget 2025: Today is the budget of India, one of the fastest growing economies in the world, the market is eyeing 10 figures

The budget of India, one of the fastest growing economies in the world, is coming. Finance Minist

Report: US President will host dinner for PM Modi, know when the Prime Minister may visit

US President Joe Biden may host a dinner for Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the middle of this y

Raveena Tandon: Kangana Ranaut came out in support of Raveena Tandon, called the incident of attack on the actress worrying

Raveena Tandon is in the headlines these days. A video of Raveena went viral on the previous day,

Health emergency in Delhi: Schools closed till 5th class, 50% of employees of government-private offices to work from home

Due to the poisonous air, people's breath is again uprooted in Delhi. Here the AQI has reached 44

China: China wants to control Pakistan's media, shocking revelation in American report

A shocking revelation has been made in an American report. It has been claimed in this report tha

Manmohan Singh Died: Dr. Manmohan Singh did not like BMW, he used to say- my car is 'Maruti 800'

Even after becoming the Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh was a simple person. To a large extent

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash