Modi's secular pitch can give BJP a new face (Comment: Special to IANS)


Posted on 23rd Feb 2015 12:17 pm by mohit kumar

The saffron brotherhood is apparently coming to terms with India's pluralism - and the constitution.

As Prime Minister Narendra Modi's observation that his government will act against any religious group inciting violence shows he has realized, albeit belatedly, that he cannot afford to maintain his "dangerous silence", to quote the New York Times, on the intimidation of minorities by Hindu groups affiliated to the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).

During his prolonged silence, he may have presumed that his backstage counsels of restraint will be accepted by groups such as the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), which have a long history of fomenting communal trouble.

That the VHP has chosen to give a contrary interpretation to Modi's speech other than what is generally supposed, by saying that the prime minister was only cautioning the Christians, shows that it remains unrepentant.

However, when the prime minister saw that his quietness was being interpreted as either weakness or acquiescence, he decided to speak out in unambiguous terms.

Moreover, by reiterating the constitutional rights about the propagation of religions and of conversions, the prime minister has turned his back on one of the most provocative of antics conjured up by the saffronties in the name of the minorities returning to their "original" faith of Hinduism via a contrived 'ghar wapsi' or home-coming ceremony.

It is not Modi alone who has recognized the norms of personal liberty. The RSS chief, Mohan Bhagwat, too, has ticked off BJP MP Sakshi Maharaj for calling upon Hindu women to bear four children each. Hindu mothers are not baby-producing factories, Bhagwat has said.

However, this advice goes against the old saffron campaign cautioning against a demographic shift in favour of the minorities with Bhagwat's predecessor, the late K.S. Sudarshan, asking Hindus to have more children.

What these deviations from the standard saffron line suggest is that the BJP may soon have a new face. The fact that it will bear a close resemblance to the "pseudo-secular" demeanours of the Congress and other non-BJP parties may be a cause of worry to the Hindutva camp, but the rest of the country cannot but welcome such a change.

It is not impossible that the latest electoral drubbing in Delhi has reminded the BJP that the people voted for it not to implement the anti-minority saffron agenda but to revive the economy which had ground to a halt under the Manmohan Singh government.

If Modi persists with his tough line against the trouble-makers of his own party and the RSS affiliates, there will be a new beginning for India in terms of both communal harmony and economic progress.

Such an initiation is likely to take the country towards the direction favoured by Nobel laureate Amartya Sen, who told the Jaipur literature festival last year that he wanted a "pro-market, pro-business party that does not depend on religious politics and does not prioritize one religious community over all the others".

The BJP has a fair chance of becoming such a party if it can marginalize its loony fringe like Britain's Labour party once did.

Now that the Congress has shown signs of pursuing a left-of-centre path since the "right-wing space does not belong to us", as party general secretary Digvijay Singh has said, there is every possibility of a straightforward confrontation between the BJP and parties like the Biju Janata Dal and the AIADMK on one side and the Congress, the communists, the DMK and the caste-based parties of the Hindi belt on the other.

In that case, the political and economic scene will have much greater clarity compared to the present when Modi's neo-liberal policies are opposed not only by the Congress, the communists and others but also by neo-fascistic elements of the Hindutva lobby.

Whether Modi will win or lose cannot be said for certain at present since he will be taking on elements that have an entrenched interest in opposing right-wing policies for varying reasons.

While the Congress opposes them because it does not want to abandon the Nehruvian concept of establishing a "socialistic pattern of society", as a 1955 resolution adopted by the party said, the communists see the pro-market approach as a surrender to American neo-imperialism.

To the RSS, capitalism is the extension of a Western model of the economy and an accompanying governing style based on individualism and consumerism which can undermine the nation's tradition-bound and abstemious heritage.

On the other hand, parties like the DMK, the casteist outfits of the Hindi heartland, the Trinamool Congress and others favour a controlled economy since, they believe, it will enable them to fill the public sector units with their party rank and file without any thought about efficiency and competitiveness.

In this Utopian, anti-American and self-serving world in which there is a curious meeting of minds between the Left and the Right, Modi remains virtually the only one among the top leaders who has recognized the need to shed the fetishes of the past and enter the present globalized economy.

He also seemingly has the tenacity of purpose to overcome the obstacles in his path such as those posed by the Hindutva Gestapo. If he succeeds, the BJP will have broken free from the shackles of the RSS.

(21.02.2015 - Amulya Ganguli is a political analyst. The views expressed are personal. He can be reached at amulyaganguli@gmail.com )

0 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

'The establishment of the Sangh on Vijayadashami 100 years ago was no coincidence,' said PM Modi at the RSS centenary celebrations.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has arrived in New Delhi for the RSS centenary celebrations. He also

IND vs SA: 'One of the 10 best innings in Indian Test history', Gavaskar praised KL Rahul's century

Lokesh Rahul's brilliant century in the first Test match against South Africa was praised by the

Everything has to be closed in the selected way so that people do not leave without needless: Allahabad High Court

The Allahabad High Court has expressed concern over the rising corona infection and an increase i

Section 144 applied in Gurugram: More than four people will not be able to gather, strict on Covid rules

Because of the increasing corona cases in the district, the Collector and Deputy Commissioner hav

Terror on the Internet: Internet playing the role of an ally in spreading terror

It is important to build a consensus among the world community to stop the use of internet media

Referring to Putin, Defense Minister Rajnath Singh said, 'India does not want to rule the world'; the reason given

Defense Minister Rajnath Singh clarified in a program on Monday that India has no intention of ru

Search on for missing Navy personnel

Panaji, March 26 (IANS) The search is still on for two Indian Navy personnel who went missing a

Mukesh Ambani gave a big responsibility to the daughter, Isha will take over the command of this company

Reliance Industries (RIL) Chairman and Managing Director Mukesh Ambani introduced his daughter Is

MI vs KKR: Chance to get rich by making him captain! These 11 players can give you a lot of progress

Mumbai Indians will clash with Kolkata Knight Riders in the 51st match of IPL 2024. Mumbai Indian

How Russia-Ukraine war is trying India-US relations

Despite the growing closeness between India and the US in recent decades, the Russia-Ukraine cris

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash