There is no judicial review of constitutional amendment: Rajya Sabha Chairman Dhankhar mentioned NJC in Justice Varma's case, know.


Posted on 26th Mar 2025 10:46 am by rohit kumar

Amid questions being raised on the independence of the judiciary in the case of Delhi High Court judge Justice Yashwant Varma, Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar has again referred to the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act.

 

No provision for judicial review of a constitutional amendment

 

Describing the NJAC as historic, Dhankhar said that if it had been implemented, things would have been different. He also said that there is no provision for judicial review of a constitutional amendment. Dhankhar said in the Rajya Sabha on Tuesday, keeping dignity in mind, this House had made a law in 2015.

 

A suitable opportunity for all of us to repeat it

 

The Parliament had passed it unanimously. The President had certified it by signing under Article 111. Now it is a suitable opportunity for all of us to repeat it. It is worth noting that the NJAC Act was brought to change the collegium system. In 2015, the Supreme Court had rejected it, terming it unconstitutional.

 

Review by constitutional provisions

 

Dhankar said that there is no constitutional provision for review or appeal of amendment in the Constitution. If any law is made by Parliament or the state, then judicial review can be done to see if it is by the constitutional provisions or not. He said that now the country is facing two situations, one is NJAC which has been passed by Parliament, supported by the state assemblies, and signed by the President and the other is judicial order.

 

Suggestion to adopt the same mechanism again

 

Dhankar said, 'I strongly urge the members to consider that no violation can be done by any institution of what is passed by Parliament and approved by the legislatures. The same mechanism should be adopted again in this case. He had also mentioned NJAC on Friday.'

1 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Rekha Gupta: Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta attacked, incident happened during weekly public hearing; accused arrested

There is news of an attack on Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta. This incident took place in the D

PM Modi: Prime Minister Modi leaves for Saudi Arabia; Many agreements will be signed; These issues can be discussed

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is on a visit to Saudi Arabia today. This visit is taking place at t

P Chidambaram on Pahalgam: When there was a ruckus over the statement, Chidambaram started clarifying, he had made a controversial comment on the Pahalgam attack

Senior Congress leader P Chidambaram came under fire from the BJP for his statement on the terror

IND vs SA Playing 11: Gill and Hardik to return to the playing XI, but who among Samson and Jitesh will get a chance? Find out.

After winning the ODI series against South Africa, the Indian team will now compete in a five-mat

Durgapur Case: Two more accused arrested in Durgapur case, Odisha Women's Commission to meet the victim's family

The Asansol-Durgapur Police Commissionerate reported that the West Bengal Police have arrested th

Atheist Krishna: 'Atheist Krishna' is no more. Rupali Ganguly expressed grief; PM Modi and Akshay Kumar had praised him.

'Atheist Krishna', who created a unique identity in the digital world due to his memes, is no mor

Was calling IAS officer Tina Dabi a 'reel star' a costly mistake? The Barmer Collector breaks her silence on the students' arrest.

Famous IAS officer and Barmer District Collector Tina Dabi is once again in the news. Tina Dabi i

Aamir Khan: All of Aamir's arrogance vanished in one meeting, he even accepted the censor board's cuts, added PM Modi's name

Producer-actor Aamir Khan has not only accepted all the cuts suggested by the censor board in his

Ajinkya Rahane did a post-mortem of KKR after the embarrassing defeat, lashed out at the batsmen for the bad season.

Kolkata Knight Riders captain Ajinkya Rahane on Sunday admitted that his team's bowling was excel

Raghuram Rajan: 'Wake up now...', former RBI governor warns government on Trump tariff; gives this suggestion

US President Donald Trump has imposed a 50 percent tariff on Indian exports. Due to this, the tex

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash