There is no judicial review of constitutional amendment: Rajya Sabha Chairman Dhankhar mentioned NJC in Justice Varma's case, know.


Posted on 26th Mar 2025 10:46 am by rohit kumar

Amid questions being raised on the independence of the judiciary in the case of Delhi High Court judge Justice Yashwant Varma, Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar has again referred to the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act.

 

No provision for judicial review of a constitutional amendment

 

Describing the NJAC as historic, Dhankhar said that if it had been implemented, things would have been different. He also said that there is no provision for judicial review of a constitutional amendment. Dhankhar said in the Rajya Sabha on Tuesday, keeping dignity in mind, this House had made a law in 2015.

 

A suitable opportunity for all of us to repeat it

 

The Parliament had passed it unanimously. The President had certified it by signing under Article 111. Now it is a suitable opportunity for all of us to repeat it. It is worth noting that the NJAC Act was brought to change the collegium system. In 2015, the Supreme Court had rejected it, terming it unconstitutional.

 

Review by constitutional provisions

 

Dhankar said that there is no constitutional provision for review or appeal of amendment in the Constitution. If any law is made by Parliament or the state, then judicial review can be done to see if it is by the constitutional provisions or not. He said that now the country is facing two situations, one is NJAC which has been passed by Parliament, supported by the state assemblies, and signed by the President and the other is judicial order.

 

Suggestion to adopt the same mechanism again

 

Dhankar said, 'I strongly urge the members to consider that no violation can be done by any institution of what is passed by Parliament and approved by the legislatures. The same mechanism should be adopted again in this case. He had also mentioned NJAC on Friday.'

1 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

Bengaluru Stampede: BJP asked sharp questions to Congress on the Bangalore stampede, and also mentioned the Allu Arjun controversy

The celebration of Royal Challengers Bangalore's victory in IPL faded when 11 people lost their l

IND vs WI: For the first time in 148 years... KL Rahul achieved a unique feat, becoming the first cricketer.

Indian opener KL Rahul scored his 11th century in his Test career against the West Indies. He sco

Only Hindus, Buddhists, and Sikhs are Scheduled Castes, CM Fadnavis said- SC caste certificates obtained by conversion will be cancelled.

Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis on Thursday said that if a person of any religion ot

Budget 2026-27: PM Modi to hold 'pre-budget' meeting with economists, focusing on tariffs and global challenges.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi will hold a high-level meeting with prominent economists and experts

IND vs ENG: Flood of criticism on India's defeat, Jadeja-Gill and Bumrah on target, know what Ashwin-Pathan and Kaif said

Team India had to face defeat against England at Lord's. Due to this defeat, the Indian team has

The challenge to the Waqf Act: 'There is a system of listing cases, we will hear the case accordingly', CJI told Sibal

The Waqf Amendment Bill has been challenged in the Supreme Court. However, it has been signed by

Mumbai RA Studio: A man held children hostage in a studio in Powai, released a video threatening to set it on fire.

A shocking incident came to light on Thursday at Ra Studio in Powai, Mumbai. A man held 15 to 20

Vijay Deverakonda's car met with an accident, and a video surfaced. The actor was returning to Hyderabad.

Actor Vijay Deverakonda was traveling from Puttaparthi, Andhra Pradesh, to Hyderabad, Telangana,

'INDIA' vs ECI: 'No permission sought yet', police on opposition alliance's march from Parliament to Election Commission

On the India Block March from Parliament to the Election Commission, the Delhi Police has said th

Jammu Blast: 'Is this an accident, a conspiracy, or something else?', Jammu DGP reveals major details about the Nowgam police station blast;

Nine people were killed and several others were injured in a deadly explosion near the Nowgam pol

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash