There is no judicial review of constitutional amendment: Rajya Sabha Chairman Dhankhar mentioned NJC in Justice Varma's case, know.


Posted on 26th Mar 2025 10:46 am by rohit kumar

Amid questions being raised on the independence of the judiciary in the case of Delhi High Court judge Justice Yashwant Varma, Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar has again referred to the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act.

 

No provision for judicial review of a constitutional amendment

 

Describing the NJAC as historic, Dhankhar said that if it had been implemented, things would have been different. He also said that there is no provision for judicial review of a constitutional amendment. Dhankhar said in the Rajya Sabha on Tuesday, keeping dignity in mind, this House had made a law in 2015.

 

A suitable opportunity for all of us to repeat it

 

The Parliament had passed it unanimously. The President had certified it by signing under Article 111. Now it is a suitable opportunity for all of us to repeat it. It is worth noting that the NJAC Act was brought to change the collegium system. In 2015, the Supreme Court had rejected it, terming it unconstitutional.

 

Review by constitutional provisions

 

Dhankar said that there is no constitutional provision for review or appeal of amendment in the Constitution. If any law is made by Parliament or the state, then judicial review can be done to see if it is by the constitutional provisions or not. He said that now the country is facing two situations, one is NJAC which has been passed by Parliament, supported by the state assemblies, and signed by the President and the other is judicial order.

 

Suggestion to adopt the same mechanism again

 

Dhankar said, 'I strongly urge the members to consider that no violation can be done by any institution of what is passed by Parliament and approved by the legislatures. The same mechanism should be adopted again in this case. He had also mentioned NJAC on Friday.'

1 Like 0 Dislike
Previous news Next news
Other news

'Please don't do this', Sonu Nigam was stoned, and students started throwing bottles and stones at the singer during the concert.

Music world's veteran singer Sonu Nigam often comes into limelight for some reason or the other.

PM Modi: Tahawwur Rana was on PM Modi's target since 2011, now a 14-year-old tweet is going viral

After the extradition of Tahawwur Rana to India, an old tweet of Prime Minister Modi from the yea

Support for the Waqf Amendment Act proved costly, mob set BJP leader Askar Ali's house on fire.

In Manipur, BJP leaders had to pay a heavy price for supporting the Waqf Amendment Act. The mob s

Saurabh Murder Case Updates: Muskan used this trick to buy an injection for anesthesia; even the officers were shocked

In the case of Meerut's Saurabh murder case, the team of the Drugs Department also came into acti

'Declare heat wave as a disaster', Parliamentary committee sends a recommendation to the government regarding heatwave.

A standing committee of Parliament has suggested that the Central government should include new a

Tahawwur Rana Extradited: What will happen to Tahawwur Rana in India, where will he be kept; What are the government's preparations, know.

Tahawwur Rana, who plotted the 2008 terror attacks on India's financial capital Mumbai, can reach

'Nothing will be gained by breaking Aurangzeb's grave', Union Minister's statement in discussion; also made a big appeal to Muslims

The political atmosphere in Maharashtra is heated over Aurangzeb's grave. One faction is demandin

'There is a big flaw in the system... Election Commission has also compromised', Rahul Gandhi raised the issue of Maharashtra elections in America

Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi has reached America. He addressed a session of stu

West Bengal: 'Assembly elections should be held next year under President's rule', statement of Shubhendu Adhikari

Leader of Opposition in West Bengal Assembly Shubhendu Adhikari has demanded that next year's Ben

Munambam Waqf Land Dispute: 'Waqf land will be investigated', Kerala HC orders formation of judicial commission

A division bench of the Kerala High Court heard the case of Munambam land dispute in Kerala on Mo

Sign up to write
Sign up now if you have flare of writing..
Login   |   Register
Follow Us
Indyaspeak @ Facebook Indyaspeak @ Twitter Indyaspeak @ Pinterest RSS



Play Free Quiz and Win Cash